IPVM has added a novel feature that rewards members who receive votes on their comments with IPVM membership credits. We are now paying out $2,000+ per quarter to members for their comments.
Voting Key Points
Here's how it works. Any member can vote on the comments submitted by other members. At the bottom of each comment, there is a series of options, simply click as appropriate. Here is an example of the voting options:
Here are some best practices on voting:
- If you already know what that commenter is posting and think it is valuable, choose 'agree'. If you did not know it, but you learned something, choose 'informative'.
- Use 'unhelpful' when the comment is off topic / unrelated to what is being discussed.
- You cannot vote for your own comments nor can you agree and disagree on the same comment.
Vote For Your Colleagues
You should vote for your colleagues as not only does it recognize their contributions, each of your votes effectively 'pays' / 'rewards' those members with membership credits.
How the Payout Works
Each 'agree', 'informative' or 'funny' counts as 1 vote each. Each 'unhelpful' is -1 votes. Disagree is neutral as we do not want to penalize members for saying something that others may disagree.
The net number of votes is used to credit member. Each vote is worth 35 cents, so a member with 10 net votes, would get a $3.50 member credit, one with 100 net votes would get $35 member credit, etc.
Pay Every Quarter
Every 90 days, IPVM does an automatic payout, sending emails to each member and crediting their IPVM accounts.
2016 Payout Results
We are now paying out $2,000+ per quarter (at ~$10,000 per year rate) for commenters. For example, ~20 members are getting $100 or more per year in IPVM member credits for their comments, paying for half or more of an annual IPVM membership.
Goal - Pay More
We want to pay more. We want members to be rewarded for commenting. This is valuable to IPVM because the more recognized commenters feel, the more good comments we get, which makes IPVM more valuable to everyone.
Very cool - I like that you aren't issuing credits just based on quantity of comments. I think we can all imagine how that would go..
Each 'unhelpful' is -1 votes, each vote is worth 35 cents...
Do you want a card number, or do you want to just roll the balance over into the next voting period? ;)
IPVMU Certified | 01/06/15 02:56pm
Let's hope I can keep up with informative, funny and agree votes as I don't want to have to pay out for any unhelpfuls. And don't vote unhelpful on this comment trying to be funny! : )
Pro Focus LLC | 01/06/15 03:41pm
Being a smaller integrator (don't call me a trunk slammer!), these credits are very valuable to me. It helps keep my cost of access down to the best resource I have found. Could I afford to pay for IPVM? Sure. Is it better to contribute and defray the cost? Absolutely!!
IPVMU Certified | 01/06/15 03:47pm
I have 2 questions:
1. Will credits be given when a person posts as undisclosed?
2. Will credits be given on votes casted during a quarter regardless of when the comment was made or is it only on your comments for a given quarter?
Wow! "You like me, you really like me!"
"I'd like to thank the Academy, my cast and crew, my agent, my makeup artist, my fellow nominees..."
No wait - that is my Academy Award speech.....
This is nice. IPVM paid for my Starbucks this week :)
IPVMU Certified | 01/07/15 02:26pm
Are there plans to add the commenting system to the mobile version of the site? When viewing on my phone, I tend to choose to view the full site even though I must pinch and zoom. I have also found that the full site runs better on my phone than the mobile version.
I dint see the options... Maybe it's not available for mobile or only some articles???
Ok, I will stick out my neck and say I do not see any value to this for a paid subscription type forum or web site. Please look at this as positive feedback as I have been very satisfied with the forum and website to date.
At my age, and having been in the security industry for a long time, this jumps out at me as a red flag. An incentive to participate on a paid forum just seems odd. This would have played a large factor on my decision to subscribe because I spent a lot of time vetting the site, prior to subscription, looking at the potential downside. I am not saying it should be a factor, only that it would have been a factor in looking for a professional site.
I don't think that an incentive to comment portrays a very professional image either. Discussions and comments should be driven by the quality of the content.
The first thing that jumped out at me was this is a marketing technique to drive up subscribers and thus advertisers, and causing a negative effect on the quality of the content by attracting unknowledgable contributors. Why not give the incentive back to subscribers in the form of a rebate on their fees?
Just my initial reaction and thoughts.
I just join IPVM and I am thrilled with this new features.
Once joined, I looked through the Articles and Discussions to find answers for my current situations and problems.
But some content lacked responses from the community.I believe with this, there will be more constructive information from the ground for me as people will see the incentives to help others with their expentise and knowledge.
Keep up the good job! :)
Do you know offhand were there more voters or votees?
Update: Commenting and voting is way up in the last 10 days.
Voting is easily up 100%. We had in the range of ~4000 votes for first three months. On the current pace, it should be over 10,000. I am glad to see that, hope it encourage more participation and rewards more members.
IPVMU Certified | 02/06/15 09:02pm
John, a suggestion in light of the 20 some unhelpful votes given in the space of just a few underlying comments and one underlying issue, in the 'what to test' thread.
Similar to other voting sites, perhaps we should change the system, at some future point, so as to tax a non-admin voting 'unhelpful' with the smallest but non-zero ding to their own total. This is not done to discourage the voting, rather just to cause some reflection upon it, and thereby reduce the retaliatory systematic down voting of multiple comments that can ensue.
More importantly, this actually strengthens the power of the 'unhelpful' since it accords the weight of 'I felt compelled to express this' to any 'unhelpful' vote that one does see.
Just a thought.
Update: quarterly payment just went out - total paid $1500, up nearly 100% from the previous quarter.
Top commenter - Chris Dearing with over $100 paid out.
More details to come in a post this week.
This is a fantastic way to keep people coming back to the site and keeping the conversations moving. Thanks!
We just sent our payments for Q2 2016 comments - over $2,000 total. Nice work everyone!
We just sent our payments for Q3 2016 comments - again over $2,000 total. Nice work everyone!
Related Reports on Tools
Hikvision Firmware Decrypted
on Mar 09, 2017
A developer has decrypted Hikvision's firmware, allowing examination of Hikvision's device source code and contents.
In this report, we overview...
Integrator Service Vehicle Guide
on Jan 23, 2017
Few assets are as commonly used by integrators and installers as their service vehicles.
125 integrators explained to IPVM in detail about their...
Smart Power Tools For Security Installs
on Jan 18, 2017
Installing a smart camera? Perhaps you should use a 'smart' drill.
The intelligent appliance / IoT trend has hit power tools.
In this note, we...
Power Drill Selection Guide
on Dec 06, 2016
Boring holes is a basic part of running cables for most security system projects. To do so, you will need to choose the right drills for various...
Viakoo Announces Free Network Monitor
on Apr 21, 2016
Intransa reincarnate Viakoo is giving away its networking monitoring service.
Viakoo released a freemium product, FreeMonitor, aimed at providing...
IP Scanners for Video Surveillance
on Feb 15, 2016
IP scanners, tools like Advanced IP Scanner, Angry IP Scanner and Fing, can be useful for setting up and managing video surveillance systems. In...
Most Recent Industry Reports
Glass Break Sensor Tutorial
on Mar 21, 2017
Burglars often break glass windows to get into a house. Using glass break detectors in conjunction with alarm contacts is a good way to protect the...
Hikvision Attacks IPVM
on Mar 20, 2017
Hikvision has attacked IPVM repeatedly over the last month, both in the international press and in its dealer communications.
VMS Update Automation Compared
on Mar 20, 2017
Updating VMS software can be a tedious and time consuming processing, which historically has required users to access each machine, download update...
Anvil Traveler Threat Management Offering
on Mar 20, 2017
A common component of enterprise security systems is traveler threat management, complementing the various physical security systems in place.
Alarm Panic Switches Tutorial
on Mar 16, 2017
Panic switches allow silently triggering an alarm system when it is otherwise disarmed. In this tutorial we explain and contrast the 7 most common...