Crappy Cameras Trigger City Surveillance Shutdown

Author: Carlton Purvis, Published on May 14, 2013

An Australian city has shut off its surveillance system after being ordered to determine how to operate its cameras without violating privacy laws. The order was passed down months after a case brought by one of its residents who argued the city had no surveillance authority and violated laws by improperly collecting personal information, including that the image quality was so poor it was impossible for the city to collect accurate depictions. A tribunal decided in the resident’s favor. In this note, we review the case.

Last Thursday, the City of Shoalhaven, in New South Wales, turned off 18 surveillance cameras in its downtown business district after being ordered by an Administrative Decisions Tribunal (ADT). The tribunal’s decision is the result of a complaint filed by Shoalhaven resident Adam Bonner. 

****** ******** **** *** **** ****** ******* ***** **** ************ cameras, *** ** ********* ** ******* ******** *********** *** ********** notified *** ****** **** ** ***** ** ********** ******. *** of *** **** ******** ********** ****** *** **** *** ****’* ****** images **** *** **** ** *** *** ******** ** ***** prevention.

******: ********** *** ****** **'* ******* **** **.**** ******** *** ****** ** **** ****. 

Crime ********** *** ***** *******
**********’* ******* *** *** *******, ***** **** ****** ** ****, were ********** *********** ** **** ** *** ****’* ***** ********** strategy,********* ** ******** *******. ************, ***** * ***** *******, *** ******* **** ** provides ****** **** ******. 

*** *********** ****** **** **** ***** ******* **** ******* *********** for **** ***** ********** ** **************. ****** **** *** ****** ******* was ** **** **** ****** ******** **** ***** *** ** able ** **** *** ****** ******** ** ****** ******* **** five ****** *** **** **** ******* ***** *** ** ****** value ** ** ************* ***** * ***** ** *********. *** of ** *********, ** **** *** **** *** *** ****** identifiable ***** ****** ******. ** **** **** **** *** ****** and *** ******** **** ******* “**** ***** ** *** ******.” Note: ** ****** ****** **** **** ********* ****** **** *** case ****. 

** *** ********, ****** ***** **** *** **** **** ******* its *** ************** *** *** ******* *** ****** ***** ******* using ******* **** (*** ********** **** ********) ** *** ****** ** * ******** *** *** ** the ******* (*** ***). 

*** ******** ******, ****** *** ****** ****** **** “********** *** **********" representations, ***** ******* *** *********** ** ******* ******** ***********. ** also **** *** ****** *** *** ******* *** ********** ********** to *** ***********. 

*******, ****** ********* *********, **** “******** *********** ** *** ********** necessary *** *** ******* ** ********* **** ***** **********” *** that “****** ****, ************ ** ****** *** **** *******, *** a ************* ************* ****** ** ***** *********.” ***** **** *** the **** ****** **** ***** *** ******** ********* ***** *** 2009 ****** ************. ** ******, **** ******* *** ********** ** crime ****** ****** *******, **** ******** *** ********.

Other ********* 

*** *********** **** ****** *** **** *** *** ******** *** law *********** ******* ********** **** ***** ********** ** ******** ***********. Police ***** *** ****** ** ******** *****, *** *** *** operate *** ******.

** *** ******* *** ************, *** ******** **** ******* ****** on *** ********* ** *** ******** ******** *** “********** ** inform * ******** ** *********** **** *** ******* *** ** operation ***, ** ***********, **** ******** *********** ** ***** *********" but *** "********** ** ****** *********** ** *** ******** *** which *** *********** ** ***** *********.”  

*** ******** ******* *** **** ** “******* **** *** ******* or ****** ** ************* ** ** *********** ********** ********* ** a ******* **** ** ********” ** **** ****** *** ******* off *** ***.

Local ******

*******, **** **** ** ****** ** **** ** ****** **** on *** ******* *** ****, *** ** **** ***. ********* to *** ********, ******* ****** ******* ****** **** ********* ** the **********’* ***** ********** ******** *** * **********. ************, ********** erred ** ******** ** *** ****** *********** *********** ** *** ********* ***** ** *** ******.****** *** ****** **** ******** *********** ******* ****, ****** *** ***. ****** **** ** ** ***** *** they *** ********** ******. ** **** ****, *** ******** ***** the ****** **** *** **** **** ** *** ****** ******, only ********* ******** ** *** ** ** ****** *****. ** *** wake ** **** ****, *******, **************** ************* ******* ***** *********** ** *********** **** ***** ***** ****** to ******* ******* *** *** *********** ********.

Overall ******

** ** *** ******* **** **** **** **** ******* ******. First, ** ******* **** **** ****** **** * ******* ** using *** ********** ***** ******* ******* ** **** ** *****-********* ones **** ***** ********** ******** ******* *****. ********, ********* ******* laws *** **** ********** ** * ******* ** ********* (****** UK ************ *** ****** - *** **************** ************ *** ******).

******:** * ****** ** ****, *** ******* ***** *'******* ********* *** regulations **** ****** ****** **** ***** ** *** ******* ***, giving **** **** ****** ******* ** ***** ** *** ***********. Cities *** *** ******* ** ******* ******** *********** ***** **** and *** ******* ** ********** **** ** ****** **** ** ** Friday *********,*** ********* ******* *******.

Comments (4)

Nowra is a country town of around 35000 and 100 miles south of Sydney. The state government is already looking to introduce legislation to bypass this decision.

Here is the relevant information for this project.

This guy is a bit of an idiot as most of the crime is related to alcoholism and occurs outside 9-5. The area has a high population on social welfare.

Source: My fiance used to live there. Her family still does.

How can personal information be collected if the cameras are too blurry to provide identification ? It seems to be a self-contradicting argument.

Alastair, I think the law still considers images being collected, blurry or not, to be "personal information." The problem was that privacy laws dictate that when personal information is collected that is has to be accurate. Bonner argued that the information collected couldn't be accurate if it was blurry and hard to make out a person's face/features.

A fair point. But it's still pretty funny.

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Global Real-Time Video Surveillance - EarthNow on Apr 20, 2018
A new company, EarthNow, with backing from Bill Gates, Airbus and more, is claiming that: Users will be able to see places on Earth with a delay...
GDPR For Video Surveillance Guide on Apr 12, 2018
The European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) comes into force on May 25, but there is much confusion and no clear guidelines on...
ISC West 2018 Access Control Rundown on Apr 06, 2018
For ISC West 2018, what is new and interesting in access control?  This rundown will bring you up to speed on the exhibitors, what they are...
VMS New Developments Spring 2018 (Avigilon, Exacqvision, Genetec, Hikvision, Milestone, Network Optix) on Apr 04, 2018
What's new with VMS software? In this report, we examine new features and releases for Spring 2018 to track different areas of potential...
30+ Emerging Tech Companies Examined on Mar 28, 2018
ISC West has a new segment for 2018: the 'Emerging Technology Zone', which they boast: Featuring 50 of the latest and greatest startup...
Audio Usage In Video Surveillance Statistics on Mar 28, 2018
Audio is more widely available and easier to use than ever, with many IP cameras building audio in and often making integration as simple as...
Understanding The 20+ Lock Functions on Mar 27, 2018
While locks can look the same, they may operate in significantly different ways. To make understanding them simpler, widely adopted industry...
Video Privacy Mask Tutorial on Feb 27, 2018
Privacy has historically been hotly debated in the surveillance industry, especially in public surveillance systems where cameras may be located in...
Chinese Police Wearing Facial Recognition Are Here on Feb 06, 2018
This is a very interesting and highly atypical usage of facial recognition that the Chinese government touted this week: It is a PRC police...
Chinese Government Attacks Western Reports on Jan 03, 2018
The Chinese government is angry at the BBC and WSJ's reporting on Chinese video surveillance (see BBC Features Dahua and WSJ Investigates China's...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Favorite Access Control Manufacturers 2018 on Apr 26, 2018
150+ Integrators told IPVM "What is your favorite access control management software/system? Why? Unlike the 2016 access favorites where a group...
Last Day Save $50 - May 2018 Camera Course on Apr 26, 2018
Today is the last day to save $50 on early registration. Register now (save $50) for the Spring 2018 Camera Course This is the only independent...
Hikvision DarkfighterX Vs Darkfighter PTZ Tested on Apr 26, 2018
Hikvision has focused on improving low-light performance for PTZs, an area that has traditionally been a problem, even more so than fixed cameras,...
Digifort VMS Profile on Apr 25, 2018
Digifort, a Brazilian company, has a strong presense in their home country. In a crowded and mature Enterprise VMS market, will they be able to...
Death Of A Dummy Camera Manufacturer on Apr 25, 2018
5 years ago, IPVM gathered insights from a dummy camera manufacturer, who was then the top selling dummy camera provider on Amazon and 3rd in all...
Hikvision Critical Cloud Vulnerability Disclosed on Apr 25, 2018
Security researchers Vangelis Stykas and George Lavdanis discovered a vulnerability in Hikvision's HikConnect cloud service that: just by...
The Yolo Bro And The Death of Journalism on Apr 24, 2018
There's an old quote: The job of the newspaper is to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable Unfortunately, the opposite is more...
DMP Adds Ring Video Doorbell Integration on Apr 24, 2018
Video doorbells have become one of the hottest items for security systems. After several years with no doorbell, DMP has announced integration with...
Milestone 2017 Financials Examined on Apr 24, 2018
For ISC West 2018, Milestone released ... their financials, touting "strong revenue growth in 2017". However, there were discrepancies with the...
Chinese Manufacturer Kickstarter Campaign Huge Success (EverCam) on Apr 23, 2018
In a week, a Chinese manufacturer's expertly done Kickstarter campaign has received $1.4 million in pledges, an incredible amount for a video...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact