Crappy Cameras Trigger City Surveillance Shutdown

Author: Carlton Purvis, Published on May 14, 2013

An Australian city has shut off its surveillance system after being ordered to determine how to operate its cameras without violating privacy laws. The order was passed down months after a case brought by one of its residents who argued the city had no surveillance authority and violated laws by improperly collecting personal information, including that the image quality was so poor it was impossible for the city to collect accurate depictions. A tribunal decided in the resident’s favor. In this note, we review the case.

Last Thursday, the City of Shoalhaven, in New South Wales, turned off 18 surveillance cameras in its downtown business district after being ordered by an Administrative Decisions Tribunal (ADT). The tribunal’s decision is the result of a complaint filed by Shoalhaven resident Adam Bonner. 

****** ******** **** *** **** ****** ******* ***** **** ************ cameras, *** ** ********* ** ******* ******** *********** *** ********** notified *** ****** **** ** ***** ** ********** ******. *** of *** **** ******** ********** ****** *** **** *** ****’* ****** images **** *** **** ** *** *** ******** ** ***** prevention.

******: ********** *** ****** **'* ******* **** **.**** ******** *** ****** ** **** ****. 

Crime ********** *** ***** *******
**********’* ******* *** *** *******, ***** **** ****** ** ****, were ********** *********** ** **** ** *** ****’* ***** ********** strategy,********* ** ******** *******. ************, ***** * ***** *******, *** ******* **** ** provides ****** **** ******. 

*** *********** ****** **** **** ***** ******* **** ******* *********** for **** ***** ********** ** **************. ****** **** *** ****** ******* was ** **** **** ****** ******** **** ***** *** ** able ** **** *** ****** ******** ** ****** ******* **** five ****** *** **** **** ******* ***** *** ** ****** value ** ** ************* ***** * ***** ** *********. *** of ** *********, ** **** *** **** *** *** ****** identifiable ***** ****** ******. ** **** **** **** *** ****** and *** ******** **** ******* “**** ***** ** *** ******.” Note: ** ****** ****** **** **** ********* ****** **** *** case ****. 

** *** ********, ****** ***** **** *** **** **** ******* its *** ************** *** *** ******* *** ****** ***** ******* using ******* **** (*** ********** **** ********) ** *** ****** ** * ******** *** *** ** the ******* (*** ***). 

*** ******** ******, ****** *** ****** ****** **** “********** *** **********" representations, ***** ******* *** *********** ** ******* ******** ***********. ** also **** *** ****** *** *** ******* *** ********** ********** to *** ***********. 

*******, ****** ********* *********, **** “******** *********** ** *** ********** necessary *** *** ******* ** ********* **** ***** **********” *** that “****** ****, ************ ** ****** *** **** *******, *** a ************* ************* ****** ** ***** *********.” ***** **** *** the **** ****** **** ***** *** ******** ********* ***** *** 2009 ****** ************. ** ******, **** ******* *** ********** ** crime ****** ****** *******, **** ******** *** ********.

Other ********* 

*** *********** **** ****** *** **** *** *** ******** *** law *********** ******* ********** **** ***** ********** ** ******** ***********. Police ***** *** ****** ** ******** *****, *** *** *** operate *** ******.

** *** ******* *** ************, *** ******** **** ******* ****** on *** ********* ** *** ******** ******** *** “********** ** inform * ******** ** *********** **** *** ******* *** ** operation ***, ** ***********, **** ******** *********** ** ***** *********" but *** "********** ** ****** *********** ** *** ******** *** which *** *********** ** ***** *********.”  

*** ******** ******* *** **** ** “******* **** *** ******* or ****** ** ************* ** ** *********** ********** ********* ** a ******* **** ** ********” ** **** ****** *** ******* off *** ***.

Local ******

*******, **** **** ** ****** ** **** ** ****** **** on *** ******* *** ****, *** ** **** ***. ********* to *** ********, ******* ****** ******* ****** **** ********* ** the **********’* ***** ********** ******** *** * **********. ************, ********** erred ** ******** ** *** ****** *********** *********** ** *** ********* ***** ** *** ******.****** *** ****** **** ******** *********** ******* ****, ****** *** ***. ****** **** ** ** ***** *** they *** ********** ******. ** **** ****, *** ******** ***** the ****** **** *** **** **** ** *** ****** ******, only ********* ******** ** *** ** ** ****** *****. ** *** wake ** **** ****, *******, **************** ************* ******* ***** *********** ** *********** **** ***** ***** ****** to ******* ******* *** *** *********** ********.

Overall ******

** ** *** ******* **** **** **** **** ******* ******. First, ** ******* **** **** ****** **** * ******* ** using *** ********** ***** ******* ******* ** **** ** *****-********* ones **** ***** ********** ******** ******* *****. ********, ********* ******* laws *** **** ********** ** * ******* ** ********* (****** UK ************ *** ****** - *** **************** ************ *** ******).

******:** * ****** ** ****, *** ******* ***** *'******* ********* *** regulations **** ****** ****** **** ***** ** *** ******* ***, giving **** **** ****** ******* ** ***** ** *** ***********. Cities *** *** ******* ** ******* ******** *********** ***** **** and *** ******* ** ********** **** ** ****** **** ** ** Friday *********,*** ********* ******* *******.

Comments (4)

Nowra is a country town of around 35000 and 100 miles south of Sydney. The state government is already looking to introduce legislation to bypass this decision.

Here is the relevant information for this project.

This guy is a bit of an idiot as most of the crime is related to alcoholism and occurs outside 9-5. The area has a high population on social welfare.

Source: My fiance used to live there. Her family still does.

How can personal information be collected if the cameras are too blurry to provide identification ? It seems to be a self-contradicting argument.

Alastair, I think the law still considers images being collected, blurry or not, to be "personal information." The problem was that privacy laws dictate that when personal information is collected that is has to be accurate. Bonner argued that the information collected couldn't be accurate if it was blurry and hard to make out a person's face/features.

A fair point. But it's still pretty funny.

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Hikvision Wins Chinese Government Forced Facial Recognition Project Across 967 Mosques on Jul 16, 2018
Hikvision has won a Chinese government tender which requires that facial recognition cameras be set up at the entrance of every single mosque...
Belgium Bans Private Facial Surveillance on Jul 06, 2018
Belgium has effectively banned the use of facial recognition and other biometrics-based video analytics in surveillance cameras for private,...
GDPR For Access Control Guide on Jul 03, 2018
Electronic access control is common in businesses plus organizations are increasingly considering biometrics for access control. With GDPR coming...
GDPR / ICO Complaint Filed Against IFSEC Show Facial Recognition on Jun 20, 2018
IPVM has filed a complaint against IFSEC’s parent company UBM based on our concern that the conference violates core GDPR principles on...
China Public Video Surveillance Guide: From Skynet to Sharp Eyes on Jun 14, 2018
China is expanding its video surveillance network to achieve “100%” nationwide coverage by 2020, including facial recognition capabilities and a...
French National Police Buy 10,400 Hikvision Body Cameras on May 31, 2018
France’s national police forces bought 10,400 Hikvision body cameras earlier this year, in a high-profile deal that’s coming into effect as the...
Dahua Products Are Not GDPR Compliant, No Products Can Be on May 29, 2018
Dahua products are neither GDPR-compliant nor certified, contrary to their marketing. The reason is that no products can be, as the EU does not...
Amazon's "Dangerous New Face Recognition Technology" Says ACLU on May 23, 2018
The ACLU has caused a stir, with a new report Amazon Teams Up With Law Enforcement to Deploy Dangerous New Face Recognition Technology,...
Genetec Clearance Face Detection / Redaction Test on May 14, 2018
Privacy regulations such as GDPR (EU Public Privacy), HIPAA (US Medical Privacy), and FERPA (US Student Privacy) are driving video surveillance...
Amazon Enters Home Security Services on Apr 26, 2018
Move over ADT? It is certainly what investors have feared for ADT, especially since Amazon acquired Ring. [Update: We spoke with Amazon and have...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Chinese OEM Avycon Gets ADI Push on Aug 15, 2018
Who is Avycon? An American company? A Korean company? A couple of guys relabelling Chinese products? The latter is the best explanation. While...
Backboxes for Video Surveillance Tutorial on Aug 15, 2018
Backboxes are a necessity in surveillance, whether for managing cable whips, recessing cameras, adding wireless radios. But it can be confusing to...
Genetec Stratocast / Comcast 'Motion Insights' Examined on Aug 15, 2018
Comcast recently announced "SmartOffice Motion Insights", an extension to their Genetec OEMed cloud video service (covered by IPVM here). This...
SimpliSafe Violating California, Florida, and Texas Licensing Laws on Aug 14, 2018
IPVM has verified that DIY security system provider SimpliSafe, founded in 2006 and acquired in June of 2018 at a billion dollar valuation, is...
Ban of Dahua and Hikvision Is Now US Gov Law on Aug 13, 2018
The US President has signed the 2019 NDAA into law, banning the use of Dahua and Hikvision (and their OEMs) for the US government, for US...
Cut Milestone Licensing Costs 80% By Using Hikvision and Dahua NVRs (Tested) on Aug 13, 2018
Enterprise VMS licensing can be quite expensive, with $200 or more per channel common, meaning a 100 camera system can cost $20,000 in VMS...
Nortek Sues SDS, Battle Over Unpaid Bill and Cancelled Lines on Aug 13, 2018
Nortek and SDS legal battle continues. As IPVM reported, SDS sued Nortek alleging bribery and antitrust violation. However, Wave fired back at SDS,...
Uniview Intrusion Analytics and VMD Tested on Aug 13, 2018
IPVM's IP Camera Analytics Shootout featuring Avigilon, Axis, Bosch, Dahua, Hanwha, Hikvision created some ill will with a Uniview distributor who...
ADT Employees Protest ADT CEO on Aug 10, 2018
So many ADT employees were so upset with ADT's CEO speech reported on by IPVM, that ADT's CEO was forced to send a mass email to employees to...
Axis / Avigilon Legal Battle Rises on Aug 09, 2018
In what is shaping up to be high-powered, will-not-back-down battle, Axis and Avigilon are squaring off in multiple legal contests. In 2017, IPVM...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact