Crappy Cameras Trigger City Surveillance Shutdown

Author: Carlton Purvis, Published on May 14, 2013

An Australian city has shut off its surveillance system after being ordered to determine how to operate its cameras without violating privacy laws. The order was passed down months after a case brought by one of its residents who argued the city had no surveillance authority and violated laws by improperly collecting personal information, including that the image quality was so poor it was impossible for the city to collect accurate depictions. A tribunal decided in the resident’s favor. In this note, we review the case.

Last Thursday, the City of Shoalhaven, in New South Wales, turned off 18 surveillance cameras in its downtown business district after being ordered by an Administrative Decisions Tribunal (ADT). The tribunal’s decision is the result of a complaint filed by Shoalhaven resident Adam Bonner. 

****** ******** **** *** **** ****** ******* ***** **** ************ cameras, *** ** ********* ** ******* ******** *********** *** ********** notified *** ****** **** ** ***** ** ********** ******. *** of *** **** ******** ********** ****** *** **** *** ****’* ****** images **** *** **** ** *** *** ******** ** ***** prevention.

******: ********** *** ****** **'* ******* **** **.**** ******** *** ****** ** **** ****. 

Crime ********** *** ***** *******
**********’* ******* *** *** *******, ***** **** ****** ** ****, were ********** *********** ** **** ** *** ****’* ***** ********** strategy,********* ** ******** *******. ************, ***** * ***** *******, *** ******* **** ** provides ****** **** ******. 

*** *********** ****** **** **** ***** ******* **** ******* *********** for **** ***** ********** ** **************. ****** **** *** ****** ******* was ** **** **** ****** ******** **** ***** *** ** able ** **** *** ****** ******** ** ****** ******* **** five ****** *** **** **** ******* ***** *** ** ****** value ** ** ************* ***** * ***** ** *********. *** of ** *********, ** **** *** **** *** *** ****** identifiable ***** ****** ******. ** **** **** **** *** ****** and *** ******** **** ******* “**** ***** ** *** ******.” Note: ** ****** ****** **** **** ********* ****** **** *** case ****. 

** *** ********, ****** ***** **** *** **** **** ******* its *** ************** *** *** ******* *** ****** ***** ******* using ******* **** (*** ********** **** ********) ** *** ****** ** * ******** *** *** ** the ******* (*** ***). 

*** ******** ******, ****** *** ****** ****** **** “********** *** **********" representations, ***** ******* *** *********** ** ******* ******** ***********. ** also **** *** ****** *** *** ******* *** ********** ********** to *** ***********. 

*******, ****** ********* *********, **** “******** *********** ** *** ********** necessary *** *** ******* ** ********* **** ***** **********” *** that “****** ****, ************ ** ****** *** **** *******, *** a ************* ************* ****** ** ***** *********.” ***** **** *** the **** ****** **** ***** *** ******** ********* ***** *** 2009 ****** ************. ** ******, **** ******* *** ********** ** crime ****** ****** *******, **** ******** *** ********.

Other ********* 

*** *********** **** ****** *** **** *** *** ******** *** law *********** ******* ********** **** ***** ********** ** ******** ***********. Police ***** *** ****** ** ******** *****, *** *** *** operate *** ******.

** *** ******* *** ************, *** ******** **** ******* ****** on *** ********* ** *** ******** ******** *** “********** ** inform * ******** ** *********** **** *** ******* *** ** operation ***, ** ***********, **** ******** *********** ** ***** *********" but *** "********** ** ****** *********** ** *** ******** *** which *** *********** ** ***** *********.”  

*** ******** ******* *** **** ** “******* **** *** ******* or ****** ** ************* ** ** *********** ********** ********* ** a ******* **** ** ********” ** **** ****** *** ******* off *** ***.

Local ******

*******, **** **** ** ****** ** **** ** ****** **** on *** ******* *** ****, *** ** **** ***. ********* to *** ********, ******* ****** ******* ****** **** ********* ** the **********’* ***** ********** ******** *** * **********. ************, ********** erred ** ******** ** *** ****** *********** *********** ** *** ********* ***** ** *** ******.****** *** ****** **** ******** *********** ******* ****, ****** *** ***. ****** **** ** ** ***** *** they *** ********** ******. ** **** ****, *** ******** ***** the ****** **** *** **** **** ** *** ****** ******, only ********* ******** ** *** ** ** ****** *****. ** *** wake ** **** ****, *******, **************** ************* ******* ***** *********** ** *********** **** ***** ***** ****** to ******* ******* *** *** *********** ********.

Overall ******

** ** *** ******* **** **** **** **** ******* ******. First, ** ******* **** **** ****** **** * ******* ** using *** ********** ***** ******* ******* ** **** ** *****-********* ones **** ***** ********** ******** ******* *****. ********, ********* ******* laws *** **** ********** ** * ******* ** ********* (****** UK ************ *** ****** - *** **************** ************ *** ******).

******:** * ****** ** ****, *** ******* ***** *'******* ********* *** regulations **** ****** ****** **** ***** ** *** ******* ***, giving **** **** ****** ******* ** ***** ** *** ***********. Cities *** *** ******* ** ******* ******** *********** ***** **** and *** ******* ** ********** **** ** ****** **** ** ** Friday *********,*** ********* ******* *******.

Comments (4)

Nowra is a country town of around 35000 and 100 miles south of Sydney. The state government is already looking to introduce legislation to bypass this decision.

Here is the relevant information for this project.

This guy is a bit of an idiot as most of the crime is related to alcoholism and occurs outside 9-5. The area has a high population on social welfare.

Source: My fiance used to live there. Her family still does.

How can personal information be collected if the cameras are too blurry to provide identification ? It seems to be a self-contradicting argument.

Alastair, I think the law still considers images being collected, blurry or not, to be "personal information." The problem was that privacy laws dictate that when personal information is collected that is has to be accurate. Bonner argued that the information collected couldn't be accurate if it was blurry and hard to make out a person's face/features.

A fair point. But it's still pretty funny.

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Startup Sunflower Labs' Autonomous Drone Security System on Dec 11, 2018
Startup Sunflower Labs is claiming a unique design on a home security system, combining autonomous drones and 'Sunflower' sensors. Imagine an...
Infinova's Xinjiang Business Examined on Dec 07, 2018
As pressure mounts for companies to stop doing business in China’s Xinjiang region amid a severe human rights crisis, IPVM has found Infinova sold...
ADT Wins Fire Death Suit But Faces Appeal on Dec 05, 2018
ADT/Protection 1 has won a wrongful death court case in which it was sued by the estate of a deceased customer. However, the attorney for the...
Cybersecurity Insurance For Security Integrators on Nov 29, 2018
Most security industry professionals carry insurance to cover themselves in the event of a general loss. However, most are not carrying cyber...
Evidence of Dahua's Involvement In Xinjiang Surveillance on Nov 28, 2018
IPVM adds new details about Dahua’s activities in Xinjiang, a Chinese region where mass surveillance used to facilitate grave human rights...
No GDPR Penalties For UK Swann 'Spying Hack' on Nov 20, 2018
The UK’s data protection agency has closed its investigation into Infinova-owned Swann Security UK, the ICO confirmed to IPVM, deciding to take “no...
Pressure Mounts Against Dahua and Hikvision Xinjiang Business on Nov 19, 2018
Pressure is mounting against Hikvision, Dahua, and other companies operating in Xinjiang as an international outcry brews against the Chinese...
French Government Threatens School with $1.7M Fine For “Excessive Video Surveillance” on Nov 14, 2018
The French government has notified a high-profile Paris coding academy that it risks a fine of up to 1.5 million euros (about $1.7m) if it...
Genetec Privacy Protector Tested on Nov 12, 2018
Genetec has built Kiwi Security's Privacy Protector into Security Center, an analytic which anonymizes individuals in cameras' fields of view...
Directory of Access Control and Intrusion Startups on Oct 30, 2018
This directory catalogs access control and intrusion detection startups IPVM has found noteworthy. The directory is provided for your review to...

Most Recent Industry Reports

ACRE-Acquired Open Options Access Company Profile on Dec 17, 2018
Who is the company ACRE is acquiring? In this note, we examine Open Options line for best customer fit, key features, pricing, and main...
Open Options Acquired By ACRE on Dec 17, 2018
ACRE is doing deals again. A year after they sold Mercury, they are buying another access control company - Open Options. In this note, we...
8MP / 4K Fixed Lens Camera Shootout - Dahua, Hikvision, TVT, Uniview on Dec 17, 2018
8MP / 4K fixed lens models are now common in lower cost lines, with nearly every Chinese brand and their OEMs now offering multiple options. To...
Network Cable Shootout - Belden, Commscope, Hikvision, Honeywell, NavePoint CCA, Windy City Wire on Dec 17, 2018
Every IP camera install needs UTP cabling. But how much of a difference is there between dirt cheap generic cables found online and the bigger,...
Hikvision Government Parent Holds Communist Party Congress on Dec 17, 2018
The Communist Party committee of Hikvision’s government parent, CETHIK, held a Party Congress earlier this month where senior executives, including...
Imperial Capital Security Investor Conference 2018 Review - ADT, Resideo, Alarm.com, Arlo, Eagle Eye, ACRE, More on Dec 14, 2018
Imperial Capital Security Investor Conference is an event matching industry executives with financiers that frequently leads to future funding...
Cisco Meraki New Cameras and AI Analytics on Dec 14, 2018
Meraki has released their second generation of video surveillance with 3 new cameras, AI-based video analytics, and 2 cloud-based storage...
Foolish Strategy: OEMing Facial Recognition on Dec 13, 2018
Almost as 'hot' as face recognition marketing right now is OEMing facial recognition. Last year, they were a who's who of company's with...
DVR Examiner - Video Recovery from Recorder Hard Drives on Dec 13, 2018
Bypassing passwords and long download times on-site, DVR Examiner collects and organizes video evidence directly from a hard drive extracted from...
2019 Access Control Book Released on Dec 12, 2018
This is the best, most comprehensive access control book in the world, based on our unprecedented research and testing has been significantly...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact