Testing HID Edge Solo

Author: Brian Rhodes, Published on Oct 03, 2013

HID is the biggest name in IP door controllers, especially for single or dual door controllers, with their Edge line. Now, as surveillance companies, like Axis and Milestone, target the access control market, competition may heat up.

HID offers a very interesting turnkey solution, "Solo", for single doors. While nearly identical in appearance and construction to HID Edge controllers, "Solo" is limited to managing a single door. It comes loaded with firmware that enables basic access control functions such as managing door locks and readers, as well as storing cardholder information, credential details, and access schedules onboard the controller. 

In this report, we share our test results of using the HID Solo with our demo door, looking at how it works and its specific weakness including operational and functional deficiencies.

*** ** *** ******* **** ** ** **** ***********, ********** for ****** ** **** **** ***********, **** ********* ****. ***, ** ************ *********, ******** *** *********, ****** *** ****** ******* ******, *********** *** **** **.

*** ****** * **** *********** ******* ********, "****", *** ****** *****. ***** ****** ********* ** ********** *** construction ** *** **** ***********,"****" ** ******* ** ******** * ****** ****. ** ***** ****** **** firmware **** ******* ***** ****** ******* ********* **** ** ******** door ***** *** *******, ** **** ** ******* ********** ***********, credential *******, *** ****** ********* ******* *** **********. 

** **** ******, ** ***** *** **** ******* ** ***** the *** **** **** ******* ****, ******* ** *** ** ***** *** *** ******** ******** including *********** *** ********** ************.

[***************]

Key ********

*** ************ ** ********** *******:

  • *****:**** ** * ****** *******, ******** ******** *** **** *** take ******* *******. ***** '******* **' **** * ******** ******** ****** ** *************, ******* ****/****** *********** ******** ****** **** *** *** ********* ***** ******* * - ** ******* **** **** *** ********** ** ** *** own******.
  • ****** *******:***** *** ********** ****** ** ** ***** *******, ************, *********, and ******* **** **** **** **** ***** ** * *** party ******** (**** *****). ******* ****** ** ****** ******, *** first **** ** ********** ** .******** ** ***** ************.
  • ** ************: *** **** **** ** * '******' ******, *** *********** the ********** ** ***** ************ ** ********* ***** ********* ** not ******** ***** *** ** ***. 
  • ******* **** *******/****** *****:**** **** **** ******* **** ***-******** **** ******* *** ***** basic ***** ** *******: *********** *****, **********, *** *******. ***** formats *** ** ********* **** (**: *** ****** *** **********), *** stored ** ********* **** ****** ** *******, **** *** *** formats.
  • ** *******/******* **: **** ********** *** ****** ***** ** ***** ** ******, and **** ****** ********* ******* * '**** *******' *** ******* of **** ****** *** *** ** **********. **** **** **** not ******* *** ********* *** **** *******, *** ** *** option ** ******/*** ******* *** ********* ******** ** *** ******.

***** *** ******** ** *** **** "****" **** **** ********* (an *** *** ***** '*** ***' *******) *** ***** ***** including * *********** ****** ** ***** *******. *** **** ***** reviews *** *** ***, *** ******/ ********** ******* ********* ************** *** ****** *** ~$***.

IP *****

*** **** **** ** * ******* ***** ****** ******. **** given * ****** ** *******, *** ****** ** ********** **** any ******* ********* ** *** **** ***. ** ******************* **** ****, ******, *** ****** *** **** **** ** *** the ********* ** *** ***** ********. *******, ** *** *** most ******** ***********, ** *** **** ********* ***** **** ****** loading **** *** ***** ******** *** ***** **** ******* ******* to ***** **. ****** ************* ******* *** *** ** ******** via *** ** ******** ****** *************, *** **** ****** ** preconfigured ** ********* ****** *** ******* ******.

Live ****** ****

*** '**** ****** ****' ** * **** ** *** ********** recent ******** *** **** ****** ******** ******** **** ******* ******* ********** of ***** ***** **** ** ********* *** **** ** *** interface. ***** **** ********** ****** **** ***** *** **** ******, options ** ******** ****/****** *** **** *** ***** ****** *** given ***** ********* *******. *** ***** ***** ***** * **** overview ** **** ******:

Adding *****/*****

*** ******* ** ****** ****** * **** ** * **** is ******** **** ******* *******. *** **** ****** * ******* of **** ***** ** *****. *** *******, ** * ****** user *** **** ******** *****, **** **** ** *** *** thousand ******* *** ****. *******, *********** **** **** *** **** falls ** *** ***** ** *** **********, **** ** *** likely * *********** **********. *** ****** ****** ** ********* * new ****** *** *********** * ********** **** ** **** ** shown ** *** ******** ***** *****:

Configuring **** **********

* ******* ****** ** *** ********** ** ******** ******* ******** to ***** *** ******** ******* ** ********. *** **** ********* offers * ********** ****** ** ********** ********** ********; ********** **** Door ****** *****, ** *** ******** *************, *** ***** ****** types *** ****. ***** ******* ** ******* (**** ***-****** *** card ******* *** ****** ******* *** *********), *** ********** ****** be **** ** ******* **** ******** ***** ******* *****. *******, more *********** ******* ********* ******** ***** (**:********) ** ***** *** ********** ******* ****** ** ********** ********** ******. The ***** ***** ******* ** ***** *******:

Reports *** ******

**** **** ****** *********** ********* ******** **** ******** ********** ************ to **** **** *** **. *** **** ****** ** *** controller ** ******* **** ****** ********** (**: **** *******, **** Events, **** *********) **** *** ********** ** * *********** **** a .************ ****. **** *****, ******** ******* (**: "**** *** **** Holder * **** **** *** **** **** ****?") **** ** filtered ** ****** ** ******* ******* *******. *** **** ***** demonstrates ****'* "******" *******:

** ********, **** ******** * ***** ****** ** '******' **** are ************ ** ******* * ****** ** ******* ******* **** 'local **** *****' - ****** *** ****** **** *** ***** - ** ******* ***** ************ ** * *** ** ***** address. ***** *** ***** ** ****** ** ***** *** ****** be ********, *** *** ******** ******* *** *****, **** ****** door ****** ************ **** ** ************ ******* ** *** ***** available. *** ***** ***** ********* **** ** ******:

Wiring *** ************

*******, ** ***** ****************, **** *** ** ************* ******* ** ******** *"**" ********** boxes ** ****** **** ** ***** ***** **********. *** ********** itself *** *** ****** *** *** *****, *** **** ******* leading ** **** ********** *** ** *** ******* ** ****** for *********. *** **********'* **** *** ******** ******** ************* ** show ** *** ***** *****:

Ideal ************

*** ******* ********** ** **** ** **** ** **** ******** one ****. ** *******, **** ********* ** *** ******** ** **** ***** ************ **** ******* individual ***** **** ******* ***** ** ******** *****, ********** *******, or ******-**** ******* *****. 

 

Comments (19)

Good device for small simple installs.

It actually is designed to fit on a single gang style electrical box. A single gang mud ring is required to mount it to a 4 square box.

RIght on Brian! I like the videos-- that is really helpful.

What’s the limitation with putting the control panel inside the reader? like , Isonas.

one less devise to install, one less cable to pull.

Hello Nidal,

Combining the reader and the controller in a single unit puts the door controller on the unsecured side of the door.

Someone could potentially knock the reader/controller off the door and gain access to lock wiring. Putting the controller outside the door leaves it more vulnerable than mounting the reader inside and away from potential vandalism or tampering.

There are a number of access products that install this way, but they really only should be used on interior, non-high security openings. See our note for more detail: Combo Reader Risk

Just my two cents, I am not an expert on the Edge Solo and I have not tried it all by itself. There are software company partners that manage the Edge solo devices.

This is from HID website: http://www.hidglobal.com/partners/networked-access HID Global offers fully-functional and easy-to-use IP-based access control solutions which, when coupled with our software providing partners, bring intelligence to the door and enable a wide variety of solution deployments including remote management and report generation via standard Web browsers, in-house enterprise solutions, hosted solutions and more.

I am currently testing it with http://www.amt-us.com/ (Automated Management Technologies (AMT)

Using their hosted solution. You can also purchase their software to do your own hosting or have the customer host it on their own server. AMT also has video integration.
Its worth checking out. I have not checked out any of the other providers but there is a lot more options with this device then just stand alone door access.

Hello, Bryce.

Thanks for the feedback. Indeed, AMT has worked with a number of companies to provide 'afterware', or additional management software for the Solo series.

Several years ago, I personally used a platform (which I believe was purchased by AMT) named 1Point from Envoy Data. In summary: it did not work that well, and support was lousy. (via Envoy Data, not AMT)

Since the stock Solo controller can be reflashed to the more stable 'E400 Host' configuration, it seemed more prudent to just take that step and use better supported platforms.

Good luck with the AMT product. Like you mention, I believe they use Axis AVHS for video integration. However, using the controller in "host" configuration as part of a larger system is going to be the most ideal option for most. As such, we are testing Genetec's Security Center Synergis module.

Regards,

  • No Integrations: The Edge Solo is a 'closed' system, and integrating the controller to video surveillance or intrusion alarm platforms is not possible using API or SDK.

As usual, John is wrong again. The Edge Solo works seamlessly in Genetec Security Center, and can then be integraded with video, intercoms, and intrusion detection. We run all 4 systems in our Genetec system, and all of our controllers are Edge Solo.

No, you are dead wrong.

Edge Solo is not the same as Edge Host. You must reconfigure/reflash the firmware to make a standalone Solo part of a Host based system. I am currently doing a test demonstrating this.

Furthermore, this finding is true of all Solo Edge readers. No platform integrates to an Edge in Solo configuration.

He said it was not possible, you said it is possible. He should have said out of the box it is not possible.

Again, this is Brian's post, not mine. Do you know how to read a byline? Here, let me help you:

Listen, you posted an arrogant, uninformed comment. Rather than doubling down or making excuses, you'd be better off being quiet or apologizing.

Who is 'he'? I wrote this report, not John. Please point out where statements disagree.

I do apologize for not looking at the author. Please see my below post for a further explanation of your inaccuracies.

"As usual, John is wrong again."

Brian has already responded on the facts of your incorrect claim. Also, I did not write this post, so you are doubly wrong. Nice job!

My apologies, as you typically make most of the mistakes, I just assumed it was you.

I would like to point out that you can find the following link in the above article:

http://www.hidglobal.com/products/controllers/edge/es400

Where you can find this exact line:

"And the EDGEPlus Solo ES400 IP Access Solution can be converted from stand-alone operation to a system reader for a host environment quickly and easily through the web browser. "

Your argument is not with me, it is with HID, and the fact that you didn't fully read linked documents.......

You need to understand that 'Edge Solo' does not equal 'Edge Host'.

As earlier stated and noted in HID's documents, it needs to be converted.

At that point, it is no longer a Solo, it is a Host. This is what is integrated into Genetec - Edge Host, not Edge Solo.

We are finalizing a Genetec access control report, including an integration with Edge Host, and you can pick that apart when it is released in the next week or two. I am looking forward to hearing from you specifically.

Thanks.

You never said that, all you said was it's "not possible." As a review of a product don't you think it's necessary to include ALL the details, not just the ones you deem as negative?

I would also like to point out that as the purveyors of a website people PAY to read it is your responsibility to separate your personal frustration from the subject matter. As Joe Schmoe the random visitor to the site, nobody expects me to say anything intelligent or act in any particular way. You, on the other hand, are expected to act in a professional matter, not to act like the teenage moderator of a pokemon forum who throws around childish insults and jabs like "here let me help you" in a sarcastic nature. I can't remember a time I was watching CNN when an anchor turned to a guest and said "Well maybe you're just a big doody head." You should have replied to my very first statement with your last statement. Stay classy IPVM.

"nobody expects me to say anything intelligent or act in any particular way"

Dustin,

I have neither the time nor interest for unprofessional, petty fighting. And I absolutely do expect members to try to act intelligently and ask questions without condemning us right off the back (especially when they are obviously wrong).

I have cancelled your company's account. Good bye.

John

Nice job John. Unreal that some are so immature and insulting. Glad Dustin is gone from the forum.

Great videos Brian, thanks very much

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Most Recent Industry Reports

Software Only VMS vs NVR Appliances on May 23, 2018
Should you buy your own PC/server and load VMS software on it or get a turnkey appliance (both hardware and software, e.g., NVR, Hybrid DVR) from a...
Buy Arecont: Top Bid $10 Million Cash on May 22, 2018
Last year, Arecont had a deal for a purchase price of $170 million (see Failed Arecont China Acquisition). This year, Arecont has a deal for a...
Installing Box Cameras Indoors Tutorial on May 22, 2018
This tutorial starts our physical installation for video surveillance series, starting with Box Cameras, one of the oldest and most basic types....
The Hikvision Smart Classroom Behavior Management System on May 22, 2018
Hikvision's rapidly growing offering of analytics, which we most recently examined with Hikvision's ethnic minority analytics, is now going into...
Dahua Intrusion Analytics And VMD Tested on May 21, 2018
Dahua ships basic analytics on practically all their cameras, ranging from low cost to high end. To see how these analytics work in real world...
Exacq Improving Technical Support, Responding To Integrator Complaints on May 21, 2018
Exacq had been a long-term favorite of integrators, but since their 2014 Tyco acquisition, Exacq has fallen in IPVM integrator studies (though...
Best Manufacturer Technical Support 2018 on May 21, 2018
While 5 manufacturers made the worst technical support 2018 list, only 3 stood out as providing the best technical support to 190+ integrators in...
Stealth / UCIT - Remote Video Monitoring Provider Profile on May 18, 2018
Can 2 remote video monitoring companies, Stealth Monitoring from the US and UCIT from Canada combine to impact the market and compete in a changing...
Cybersecurity for IP Video Surveillance Guide on May 18, 2018
Keeping surveillance networks secure can be a daunting task, but there are several methods that can greatly reduce risk, especially when used in...
Forced Entry / Duress Access Tutorial on May 17, 2018
Even though access control normally keeps people safe, tragedies have revealed a significant issue. If users are forced to unlock doors for...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact