Face Detection Shootout - Dahua, Hanwha, Hikvision, Uniview, Vivotek

By Rob Kilpatrick, Published Jul 30, 2020, 10:43am EDT

Face detection analytics are available from a number of manufactures including Dahua, Vivotek, Hikvision, Uniview, and Hanwha, but how well do they work?

IPVM Image

We tested face detection analytics across these manufacturers examining:

  • Can faces still be detected wearing masks, hats, or sunglasses?
  • Can faces be detected at harsh angles?
  • How well do they detect faces in full light?
  • How well can faces be detected in low light (~2lx)?
  • How well can faces be detected in the dark with IR (~0.02lx)?
  • Are there issues detecting faces in WDR scenes?
  • Do these analytics integrate with third-party VMS?

Ranked *******

***** ** *** ******* face ********* *********** ***** into ***** ******:

IPVM Image

  • *** **********:***** *** ****** ********* best ** *** *****, with ********** ********* ** full *****, *** ***** (~0.2lx), **** (~*.****), *** WDR ******, ******* ******* angles *** ********* ******, and *** ** ****** detecting ******** ******* *****, sunglasses, ** ****.
  • *******:********* *** ******* **** detected ***** **** ** full ***** *** ** scenes, *** *** *** handle ***** ****** ** well ** *** **********, sometimes ******* ******** ** 45° ****** ** *******. Both ******* ********** ******** faces ******* *****, **********, or ****. *******, ******* manufacturer ******** ******** ***** in * *** ***** test ***** (~* ***) as ***** **** ******** by ******* ***** *** dimmer ******.
  • ***** *******:******* **** ********* ********* worst ** *** *****, detecting ******** **** ** shallower ****** **** ****** (up ** **° / 33° ********), ************ ****** subjects ** *** ***** and **** ******, *** failed ** ****** ******** in *****.

*******

***** *** ******* *** findings **** *** *******:

  • *** ******* ****** ***** In **** *****:** * **** ***** setting, *** ******* ****** were **** ** ****** a **** **** **** harsher ********* (~**°).
  • ********* **** ********** ** ~45°, ***** *** ****** Detect ** **°:*** ******* ***** **** Hikvision ******** ***** ******* toward *** ****** ** ~45°, ***** *** ****** were *** **** ******* that ****** * **** at **°.
  • ******* ****** ***** *** to ** ************:** * **** ***** of ~*.****, *** ******* detected ***** ************ ****** for ******* ***** *********** the ******** **** ** the ********* ****.
  • ****** *** ***** ****** Faces ** *** ***** (~2lx): ** * *** light ******* ****** *** Dahua ******** ***** ** the ***** ***** *********, Vivotek, ******* ****** ************.
  • *** ******* ****** ***** In *** *****:** ******* *** ****** detecting ***** ** * WDR ***** ***** ***** own *** *******.
  • *** ******* *** ******* Detected ***** **** ******* Masks ** **** *****:******** ******* ******* *** scene ******* * ******* mask **** ******** ** all *** ******* *******.
  • *** ******* ******** ***** Wearing **********/***:*** ******* ******** ***** wearing ********** *** * hat ****** ******* ******* missing ***** ** **** mounting ******* (~**') *** downtilts (~**).

Others **** ******* **** *********

******* ***** ***** ************* do *** ***** **** detection ** ***** *******, so **** *** ******** in **** ****.

  • ********:******** ****** ****** *********** (********** ******) *** ** **** not ***** ****** **** detection.
  • ****:**** **** ****** **** detection ** ********* ************** ***, ***** ** compatible **** **** ***** modular **** ****** *** is ******** *** **** video ****, *** **** not **** **** ********* events ** ***.
  • *****:***** ****** **** ********* as **** ** ******** ****** *********, *** ** ** used *** ****** ********* for ****** *********** ******** and **** *** ******* VMS ******.
  • *********:**** ********* ** ******** only ***********'* ******* ********.

All ******* ****** ***** ** **** *****

** * **** ***** setting *** ******* ****** detected ***** **** * person ******* ******** ** the ****** ** ******** downtilts ** ** ** ~33°.

IPVM Image

Hikvision **** ***** ** ~** ***** ****** *** ***** ****** ** **° **********

*** **** **** ********* to **** ****** ** ~45° *** *********, ********** across *** ********* ******* tested, **** *** ** high ***.

IPVM Image

******* *** ******* ************ detected ***** ** **° angles, *** ****** ************ beyond.

IPVM Image

****** *** ***** **** detection **** **** ** detect ***** **** ****** walking ****** *** ***** at **°, ***** *** other ************* ****** **********.

IPVM Image

Dark / ** (~*.****) ***********

** * **** *******, Hanwha *** ***** **** detection **** ***** ******** faces ** ****** ******** heights (~**') *** ********* (~33°) ******* ******** ** the ****** *** ~**° angle ** *********.

IPVM Image

**** ** **, *********, Vivotek, *** ****** ******** the ******* ** ** essentially ****** *** ******, but ******** ***** **** at ***** ********* (~**°).

IPVM Image

*******, ******* ********* ****** faces ** *** **** with ** ** *** to ** ************, *** present ** ***** *******.

IPVM Image

Hanwha *** ***** ************ ****** ***** ** *** ***** (~*.***)

** *** *****, ****** and ***** **** *** only ******* ** ************ detect ***** ** * low ***** ***** (~*.***) performing ********* ** **** light **** ** **° downtilt.

IPVM Image

***** *********, *******, *** Dahua **** **** ** sometimes ****** ***** **** consistently ******, **** ** lower ******** ******* (~*') and ********* (~**°).

IPVM Image

All ******* ****** ***** ** *** *****

*** ************* **** **** to ************ ****** *** face ** * ****** walking ******* *** ***** using ***** *********** ********, even ****** ****** ******* were *******.

IPVM Image

All ************* *** ******* ******** ***** **** ******* ***** ** **** *****

****** ******* ***** **** detected ************ ***** ******* a **** ** *********, Dahua, ******, *** ******* in ******* ******, *********** similar ** ***-**** ***********.

IPVM Image

******* ***** ****** **** detections **** ******* *****, even ** ***** ***** and ******* ********.

IPVM Image

All ******* ******** ***** ******* **********/***

*** ******* ****** ******** faces ******* ******* *** scene ******* **********, * hat, ** * *********** of **** ** ******* scenes.

IPVM Image

Bounding ***** **** **** ** ********

******, *****, *******, *** Vivotek *** ***** * bounding *** **** * detected **** **** ****** in ***** *** *** interface.

IPVM Image

**** ********* **** *** provide * ******** *** when * **** ** detected.

IPVM Image

*******, ****** ** *** only **** ********* **** provides *****-** ******** ***** when ****** ** * VMS.

IPVM Image

VMS ************

****** **** ********* *** the ****** ***** ***********, integrating **** ***********, *******, NX *******, *** *********. Hikvision **** ********* ***** the **** **** **********, integrating **** ***********, ** Witness, *** *********. ***** Integrated **** ** ******* and *********. ******* **** integrated **** ******* *** their *** ***. *******, Uniview *** *** ********* with *** ***, **** with ***** *** ***.

IPVM Image

Versions ****

*** ********* ******** **** used ****** *******.

  • ********* **-*********-****: **.*.** ***** 190919
  • ********* **-**********-****: **.*.* ***** 190923
  • ****** ******* : *.**.**
  • ******* ****** - ****: 0121d
  • ******* **********-***: ************-*************
  • ***** ******* : **.***.*******.**.*, Build ****: ****-**-**

Comments (15)

Undisclosed Integrator #1

07/30/20 05:21pm

******* *********** *** *********** test, ****** **** ****!

Undisclosed Manufacturer #2

07/30/20 06:13pm

**** ***** ***** * red * *** ****** and ******* *****. *'* also ****** ********* ** doesn't **** **** ********* considering *** ***** ********* work.

Avatar

Rob Kilpatrick

IPVM | IPVMU Certified | In reply to Undisclosed Manufacturer #2 | 07/30/20 10:26pm

***, ****** *** ******** that ***, * ******* the ***** ** ******* the ****. ** ******* out ** ********* ** confirm *** **** ********* events ******* *** **** get **** ** *** when **** *****.

Avatar

Rob Kilpatrick

IPVM | IPVMU Certified | In reply to Undisclosed Manufacturer #2 | 07/31/20 08:23pm

***, ********* ********* **** clarification ** ********* ***********, I ****** ******* *** cameras *** ******, *********, and ***** ********** **** detection ****** ***** ******* and ******* *** ***, I ******* *** ***** and **** ** ******* this.

Cory Knight

NMS | IPVMU Certified | 07/30/20 08:08pm

** ***** *** ********** that ********* **** ***** these ******** ** *** future?

Avatar

Jared Tarter

Milestone Systems
In reply to Cory Knight | 07/31/20 10:34pm

*** ********* *** ******* above ** ******** ** UM2 *** **** ********* worked ** *** ******, Hikvision, *** ***** *******.

Avatar

Salvatore D'Agostino

IDmachines | 07/31/20 12:57am

***** *** ****************** ********* **** **** in ***** **** ***** is **********. ** ***** be *********** ** **** which ********** **** *** code *** ** ********** onto * ****** ***/** VMS ********. **** *********** results ** *** **** report ********* ** ******* performance **** ***** (***-***** 19) *** ** **** at **** ************ ***** occur ** ************* ******* this ********* *** ** they ****** **** ********* as ****. ** *** know ** *** ** these ******* (***** **** Dahua) ****** ** *********** in ******* **** *******?

**** *** ******* ***** getting ************ ** ******* to ********** *** ****** how ***** ** **** pitted ******* ****-************ **********?

Avatar

Salvatore D'Agostino

IDmachines | In reply to Salvatore D'Agostino | 07/31/20 01:42pm

IPVM Image

Avatar

Salvatore D'Agostino

IDmachines | In reply to Salvatore D'Agostino | 08/02/20 05:24pm

****************** ** ****** *********** and **** *****

Avatar

Salvatore D'Agostino

IDmachines | 07/31/20 01:43pm

***** **** *** ******** the ****** ****** ***** recognition... *** ******* *** the ************ * **********.

Undisclosed Manufacturer #3

07/31/20 09:30pm

****** **** *** **** detection **** *** **** overlay ** ***** **** and ***-**** *** ******. You *** ****** *** color ** *** ******* as **** ** **** on ****** **** ** "RECORDING ** ********" **** the ****** ** ***** the **** ** **** to *** *********. **** helps ***** ********* ** retail ******.

Undisclosed Manufacturer #4

09/10/20 07:46am

*** **** **** ******** is *** * **** of *** ****

Avatar

Ethan Ace

IPVM | In reply to Undisclosed Manufacturer #4 | 09/10/20 04:38pm

******** *** *** ******** because **** ** *** simply ***** **** ********* in ***** ******* ** ACC. ****** *********** ** available ** ***, ***** we ****** ****:******** ****** *********** '********** Alerts' ******

Avatar

Tyler Graham

10/29/20 03:40pm

** ** **** ******* to *** *** / LPC ***** ***** * lot ** ******* *** capture * ******* ***** but **** *** *** recognize ****? *** *** detecting ***** ** **** test *** **** *** you ** **** **** information ***? ** *** idea ** **** ********* for *** *** ** face ***********?

Avatar

David Johnson

10/29/20 04:02pm

*****, * ***** ** interested ** **** *** if **** ***** **** detection *** ********* **** a ********** ******** ** the ******* ********* ********* that ***** ** **** whether *****-***** *** ** separate ***/***. ** ** that's *** **** *** to ****** *** ******** events **** *********.

Read this IPVM report for free.

This article is part of IPVM's 6,817 reports, 914 tests and is only available to members. To get a one-time preview of our work, enter your work email to access the full article.

Already a member? Login here | Join now
Loading Related Reports