Honestly. They’re all terrible. They all have some major flaw IMO. Video doorbells are by far our most requested product from both business and residential customers. We get more requests for video doorbells than anything else.
Ive tried nearly every doorbell I can find and I still have not found one I’m 100% confident in.
Between power requirements, WiFi requirements, app and installation user friendliness, and storage options. No one really has everything we need in one package.
I would agree. I like the Nest Hello and it seems to work fairly well. The major issue is that it doesn't support ONVIF. I would really like all the features the nest offers, but would like to record the data on my own system. The Wisenet SmartCam D1 has worked well for my own purposes because I can get the human detection alerts but record the RTSP stream to Spectrum. This has been working well for many months now. The native app isn't my favorite though and loses big time to Nest in terms of app quality/speed.
I haven't found a doorbell scenario yet where the doorbell hasn't worked. I have integrated two on a NuTone intercom system (meaning chime activation on Nutone) and on the constant power 8-note mechanical chimes. A relay and 24VAC transformer is needed, but that solution works well.
The Dahua and Hikvision wouldn't work on many of the doorbells I've encountered. Those form factors are too big. However, the other Hikvision doorbell is smaller.
In fairness, you have to understand Dahua's and other Chinese manfacturers beta release program. This is more than likely a beta product. One in which they have released to all of their beta testers. When I say beta testers, I mean the general public.
Thanks for the help. 'I checked the option to subscribe to the doorbell device under 'Alarm Manager'. It was partially successful, but the unit still does not work as expected. Push notifications work, but video/audio calls did not.
Here are some screenshots:
Below is a push notification when the button is pushed
Opening iDMSS from that notification cannot open a video or audio session with the doorbell:
The notice that follows on the phone shows an unsuccessful 'CallNoAnswered' log, although it was attempted.
Thanks for the help. Your suggestion prompted deeper response than previous tech support attempts, which is positive. However, it still does not work, and like we note in our report above this level of troubleshooting/trial and error is beyond what is needed with basic consumer products.
It should not take that much work to make a doorbell work.
I installed an ADC doorbell at my house and it took just a few minutes and everything worked fine.I did have an issue where I could not stop notifications on motion. I opened a ticket and they quickly pointed out I had notifications configured under notifications and video. They suggested I delete all rules under video. That solved the issue.
Point being ADC made it easy and was able to resolve my issue. They also have a huge FAQ and knowledge base.
Dahua makes it hard, no manuals,no documentation, etc on most of their products. NOBODY should have to work that hard to get a ~$200 item to work.
Given the demand, I commend IPVM for testing these doorbells, and I am looking forward to more tests and shootouts!!
I have no financial interest in saying this, but the dbell product caught my eye since it's supposedly ONVIF compatible, able to connect to a NVR and they are a Canadian company. Another curiosity for me on the dbell product is the altogether new chime box so the legacy 16VDC wiring is not an issue. I recommend IPVM consider their product for a future review.
Regarding wiring, POE/POE+ wiring should be a plus for video doorbells and not a minus. Legacy 16VDC wiring predates the explosive growth of IP cameras, and it's way past due to change this paradigm IMHO and I'm surprised IPVM isn't beating this drum. More and more DIYers are installing their own IP camera networks, and the criticism of not using existing 16VDC wiring is akin to criticizing these "newfangled" IP cameras are not compatible with existing analog coax wiring (and we know how that turned out). I think there is a market segment yearning for a POE video doorbell with push notifications that is ONVIF compliant, even if it's not the public masses (yet).
More and more DIYers are installing their own IP camera networks, and the criticism of not using existing 16VDC wiring is akin to criticizing these "newfangled" IP cameras are not compatible with existing analog coax wiring
Any criticism comes due because doorbell chimes and transformers do not use PoE, but two wire 16 VAC. The vast majority of retrofit applications will not have PoE available at the doorbell, and running new cable to that point is pretty advanced for 'DIY', especially when the doorbell is marketed as 'WiFi'.
PoE certainly is useful. In this case it is not the utility most users already have at the intended point of use.