Cameras, Used to Deny Disability, Struck Down

By: Carlton Purvis, Published on Jul 11, 2013

Is your mom lying about being disabled to get free bus rides? A Canadian city is so determined to stop her that they have deployed thousands of cameras to catch her in the act. But hold on. These cameras have been struck down. In this note, we break down their approach, what was found to be at fault and what needs to happen next to continue surveillance usage. 

City Investigation 

After an investigation by the city ombudsman (full investigation report), the Toronto Transit Commission has stopped using surveillance in para-transit service vehicles to asses passengers’ levels of disability. The investigation found that camera footage was being used in hearings to deny passengers service. Those passengers were never told footage was being collected making them unable to fairly defend themselves in cases where a disability changes the amount of mobility from one day to the next.

Background

The Wheel-Trans program is a door-to-door transit service for disabled riders. From 2006 to 2007, the city fitted Wheel-Trans vehicles with cameras for “crime deterrence and the safety and security of passengers and staff.” By the end of 2008 more than 7,000 cameras were installed in transit vehicles. In 2010 TTC expanded the scope of the cameras, using them to verify the customer eligibility.

** * ****** ********* that * ***** *** not **** * ********** (or ******* ********) *** initiates * “************ *****” investigation. The ***** **** ** a *** ************* ******** pulling ***** **** *** rider’s ****** *****-***** *****. An ************* ***** **** a ****, *** *** rider **** *** *** is ***** **** ***** was **** ** *** assessment. ***** **** *********, 70% (**) ** “************ riders” ******** ** **** and **% (**) ** 2011, **** ****** ********** for *******.

Policy *********

********* * ********* ******* TTC,**** ** ******* *********, ***** *****, opened an investigation in to TTC’s surveillance camera use. The final **-**** ********* ******** **** ****. The ********* ***** **** TTC ******** *** *** policy **** ******** ****** consultations ****** ********* ************ camera ***. ** **** ***** that *** *** * poor *** ********* ********** that ******* ***** ** used ** ********* ***********. TTC *** ***** **** decals **** *** ********* says **** “** ***** that **** ****** ******’* notice **.

*** ****** ******** **** image ** * ***** (but *** *** **** the ****** **** *********). 

[******]: ***** **** *** ****** were ** *** ***** below *** *******. ***** dimensions **** *.* ** 3.75 ******. 

Unfair ************** 

*** ***** ******* *** that *** ******* ********* an ****** ********* ** a ******’* *********. *** report **** ******* ********* from ****** *****-***** ******.

“**. *” *** *** eligibility ********** ***** * panel ******** ***** ** her ***** ******* ********. “She ********* **** ** she *** **** ***** recorded ****** *** ******, when *** *********** **** difficulty *******, *** ***** would **** **** *** challenges. **********, ** *** video ********* *** ***** during *** ******, ** would *** ********** ******* the ****** ** *** disability,” *** ****** ****. Other ********** *** ***** eligibility ********** ***** ***** footage ****** **** ************ walking ********** ** ** days **** **** *** not ** ****** ** debilitating. ******* ******* *********** said *** ****** **** her ************ **** ********** to ******* ***** ***********. The ***** ***** *** ineligible *** ********.

*** ********* **** ***** video ******* ********** ******* telling **** *** ****** and *** *** **** passengers * ****** ** defend **********. **** **** aware **** ******* **** the ******* ***** ** used ******* ****, *** some **** **** ***** have **** ***** ** explain ***** ********* ** present *********** **** * ****** at *** ******* ** they *** ****.

*** ********* ****** ** recommendations ** *** *** that ********:

  • ********* *** ***** ** make *** ******* ******** 
  • ******* ************ *********** ** the **** ** *** pages *** ********
  • ********** * ****** ************ on ********* *** ***** of *** *******
  • ******** ****** ** *** footage *** ****** ********** in ******** 
  • ******** *** ****** ************ since **** ** ******* for *******

*** ****** ** ****** with *** ** *** ombudsman's ***************. 

Other ********** **** *** ******

************ *** ** ***** ******** Cities

** ** ***** ***** cities **** ****-******* ******** (Calgary, ********, ********, *********, London, ********, ******, ****** City, ********* *** ********) half **** ************ ** their ********, *******, ******* is *** **** *** to *** ************ ** determine ***********. *** ****** **** their ******* ******* *** using ************ *** “****** ****** and ********.” ***** **** included ******** ************** *** physical *** ******** ****** investigations.

**** ** *** ******* providers *** ******* ** their ********. **** *** additional *********** ** ***** websites.

Cameras ** *** **** *** ***** *****

**** *** ******* ** extra *** ** *********** that *** ** ******* along **** ***** ***********, but **** *** ***** a ******** *** ******** record ** ** *****. Cameras *********** ******** ** ***** items,***** ***************** ********, *** **** ** this ** **** ******* just ** **** *********** coming **** ******* *** camera. *** ***** ** ignoring ***** ******* ** evidence *** ******* **** weight ** ************ ******* than ********* **** ********** or ******’* *****. 

 

Comments (0)

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Most Recent Industry Reports

Sighthound Transforms Into Enterprise AI Provider on Jun 14, 2019
Sighthound is now rapidly expanding its R&D team, building an enterprise AI service. This may come as a surprise given their origins 6 years...
ADT Eliminating Acquired Brands, Unifying Under 'Commercial' Brand on Jun 14, 2019
ADT is eliminating the brands of the many integrators it has acquired over the past few years, including Red Hawk, Aronson Security Group (ASG),...
NSA Director Keynoting Dahua and Hikvision Sponsored Cybersecurity Conference on Jun 13, 2019
The technical director for the NSA’s Cybersecurity Threat Operations Center will be keynoting a physical security cybersecurity conference that is...
Farpointe Data Conekt Mobile Access Reader Tested on Jun 13, 2019
California based Farpointe Data has been a significant OEM supplier of conventional access readers for years to companies including DMP, RS2, DSX,...
Embattled $400 Million China Funded Philippines Surveillance System Proceeds on Jun 13, 2019
An embattled 12,000 camera surveillance system project that will cost ~$400 million will proceed.  The project contract was awarded, had its...
False Verkada 'Unrivaled' Low Light Performance Claim Removed on Jun 12, 2019
Verkada falsely claimed that it delivered 'UNRIVALED LOW LIGHT PERFORMANCE' until IPVM questioned. In fact, Verkada's low light performance is...
Manufacturer Favorability Guide 2019 on Jun 12, 2019
The 259 page PDF guide may be downloaded inside by all IPVM members. It includes our manufacturer favorability rankings and individual...
Camera Course Summer 2019 - Register Now on Jun 12, 2019
Register for the Summer 2019 Camera Course.  This is the only independent surveillance camera course, based on in-depth product and technology...
Favorite Wireless Manufacturers 2019 on Jun 12, 2019
Many wireless options exist for video surveillance but how are integrator's overall favorites? 170 integrators answered the question: What is...
Carnegie Mellon AI Startup Zensors Profile on Jun 11, 2019
Zensors is a startup formed by Carnegie Mellon graduates from a Carnegie Mellon research project, offering customized models per camera that they...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact