Camera Video Display Problems Tested

By: Ethan Ace, Published on Mar 18, 2016

In the old days, displaying video was simple. Both cameras are monitors were generally the same aspect ratio, so it was fairly simple to display video without any problems.

Now, though, with various aspect ratios (16:9 monitors, 4:3 cameras, 16:9 cameras, fisheye streams, multi-imagers, etc.), this is becoming much more difficult.

Indeed, many VMS clients are now defaulting to cropping or warping video by default.

In this report, we look at this problem and share examples of how Axis, Dahua and Hikvision do this.

** *** *** ****, displaying ***** *** ******. Both ******* *** ******** were ********* *** **** aspect *****, ** ** was ****** ****** ** display ***** ******* *** problems.

***, ******, **** ******* aspect ****** (**:* ********, 4:3 *******, **:* *******, fisheye *******, *****-*******, ***.), this ** ******** **** more *********.

******, **** *** ******* are *** ********** ** cropping ** ******* ***** by *******.

** **** ******, ** look ** **** ******* and ***** ******** ** how ****, ***** *** Hikvision ** ****.

[***************]

Cropping *******

***** *** *** *** problems ****, ******** *** stretching.

******* *** *** ****** below, ****** *** **** it '*****' *** ****, the *** *** ****** are *******:

**** ********* ***** ***** it ** ******.

Stretching *******

******* *** *** ****** below, *** ******** *** is * **:* ****** ratio ****** *** *** VMS ******** ** ***** / *********:

** *** ********** *****, you *** *** *** the *** ** **********:

*********

********* *** ****** ****** for ****** ****** *****. By *******, ********* *******, DVRs/NVRs, *******-**** ****** ******* ***** ** the ******, ********** ** aspect *****. *** ****** image ** ******* (****** Axis, *****, ***** ***** parts ** *** *****), but ********* ** **** cases.

**** *** ** ******* to ******* ****** *****, but *** ****** ** buried ** ******** (**** > ****** ************* > Image > **** ***** > ******** **********). *** image ***** ***** *** same ******* ** *****, all **:*, ** ***** proper ******.

Axis ****** *******

** ******* ****** ******* * test, ******* *** *** to "****" *** **** by *******. **** *********** means **** *** ********** width ** *** ***** is *** ** *** width ** *** ******* pane. *******, ***** ** the *** *** ****** of *** *** *** cut ***.

**** *** ** ******* in ************* ** *** the **** ***** ** the ****, ***** ******** the **** ***, *** results ** ******* ****** of ***** ***** ** either ****, **** *****. However, ***** **** ******, at ***** *** **** FOV ** ******* *** aspect ***** ** *********.

*****

** ***** *** **********, aspect ***** ** *** respected, ******** ****** ******** defaults ** "******** ****** ratio", **** ******* ** stretch ** ****. **** can ****** ** ******* stretching ********* ** *** window ****** ***** *** size.

*** *******, *** ********** below *** ***** **** the *** ********* ** a***** ** *****. ********** ** *** window ******, ***** ** still ********* ** **** the ***** ** *******, resulting ** ******** ** stretched *****. ***** *** controls ** **** ***** in *** ******** ******, but **** *** *** well ******* *** *** users *** *** ******* they *** **** *****.

The ********

****** ***** **** ****** be ********* ******, *** two *******:

  1. Monitors *** **:*, *** **** ******* *** ***: Though many would like to proclaim HD and 16:9 formats as the way to go, 4:3 models are still commonly used (and arguably provide more useful images), including 3 MP, 5 MP, and now 12 MP resolutions. It will be years before 4:3 is no longer available.
  2. UI ******** **** ** *****: Toolbars, Windows and Mac task bars, event lists, and other UI elements take up screen space, meaning even if the VMS client is run full screen on a 16:9 monitor with 16:9 cameras in a split view, these controls may take up space and skew the aspect ratio of viewing windows.

****** ***, *** ******** is ** **** ********** camera ****** *****. ****** some *** ******** **** viewing ******* "********", **** ultimately ******* **** ****** usability *** ** *** issues *****. ***** ***** between ***** ** * better ******** **** ******* distorted *****.

Comments (7)

Though some may consider full viewing windows "prettier", they ultimately detract from system usability due to the issues above. Blank space between panes is a better solution than viewing distorted video.

I would disagree.

First, I don't consider stretched windows prettier, just the opposite, wide faces, bodies etc.

Second, this is not Avatar in 3D. The primary goal is not photographic realism, it's effective information transfer.

For me, stretching the screen to fit the size makes it easier to see movement when not looking directly at the pane.

In any event it does not mislead me in any way, since I know the true aspect ratio.

On the other hand, the difference/distortion of the color pallete by even cameras of the same mfr/model, is something that could materially affect an investigation. Do you agree about color distortion?

Maybe a poll?

"Do you prefer stretch to fit windows over letterboxing?"

I can understand the advantage you described of filling all the pixels. I do think the correct aspect ratio does improve identification to some degree. The ability to discern someone's "build", is easier if the aspect ratio is correct.

I hate it when windows are stretched and distorted. It's difficult to evaluate things like focus and other criteria. It is one of my pet peaves with Dahua's web interface for IP cams in the live view tab. The first thing I click is the "Original" instead of "Adaptive" aspect ratio.

It's difficult to evaluate things like focus...

Absolutely. But is this an installer concern more than a user concern?

For instance given a 1080p 50" that is part of a video wall, which can you discern important details better from across the room with?

This:

or

Things like "is someone at the end of the hall?" are easier to make out because there are more pixels displaying them. The fact that the chairs are really taller than they appear is unimportant IMHO.

And what is the downside to the user exactly?

Unintended scene cropping, on the other hand is an abomination, and deserving of criticism.

I have a difficult time understanding how stretching the video feed to fit the window size has any impact on security monitoring (or is even worth writing about really). If someone is watching the video feed in realtime (all the time), their brain will adjust what they see. If they aren't watching realtime (all the time), then post incident analysis is the only situation you can assume. In a post incident analysis situation, manipulating the aspect ratio is reasonable if in fact it really bothers the investigator.

In any case, cropping is obviously the worse of the two. Destroying information is worse than transforming information (there is no loss of information when you distort the image to fit the window - you can transform it back).

I think it depends on who is watching. A security professional wants to keep the true nature of the video and the aspect ratio.

A typical "end user" has been told that black bars are bad. That is why you had to go out and replace your CRT 4:3 TV with a new 16:9 expensive HDTV. They don't want to see "wasted space" on their VMS display. Even if the cameras are higher resolution - 3mp vs 2 mp, they will question it. I think that it takes educating the end user, and ultimately giving them the option in the settings, as long as the true video is still preserved as evidence...

Of course, now movies are in newer aspect ratios, and there are still black bars. And many TV shows are stretched in different amounts from the center out.

Interesting topic! I think perspectives about this vary a lot, so I guess there can be no clear winner. Personally, I don't like cropping at all, and I'm surprised Axis ACS does it. It is common in most Chinese cameras' Web interfaces, though... Do many of the major VMS' clients (Genetec, Milestone, Exacq...) crop too?

About VMS clients now warping by default, I expected the tendency to be the opposite, and anyhow, changes being uncommon since users will probably be used to what they have, so manufacturers will be reluctant to make big changes and disappoint them... Do you know of any important change in this aspect, from any of the main players?

Thanks for the article!

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Axis ~$150 Outdoor Camera Tested on May 21, 2019
Axis has released the latest in their Companion camera line, the outdoor Companion Dome Mini LE, a 1080p integrated IR model aiming to compete with...
Panasonic 32MP Multi Imager Camera Tested (WV-X8570N) on May 16, 2019
Panasonic has released their first multi imager models including the 32MP (4x4K) WV-X8570N, claiming "Extreme image quality for evidence capturing...
Bank Security Manager Interview on May 15, 2019
Bank security contends with many significant threats - from fraudsters to robbers and more. In this interview, IPVM spoke with bank security...
Milestone XProtect 2019 R1 Tested on May 15, 2019
For the past few years, Milestone has released quarterly software updates XProtect VMS platform. What is new and how much impact do the updates...
Bluecherry Open Sources Entire VMS on May 13, 2019
Bluecherry announced they have "released the entire Bluecherry software application open source with a GPL license". We spoke to Bluecherry's...
Mining Company Security Manager Interview on May 10, 2019
First Quantum Minerals Limited (FQML) is a global enterprise with offices on 4 continents and operations in 7 countries with exploratory operations...
Aegis AI Gun Detection Video Analytics Startup on May 07, 2019
Gun detection analytic startups are increasing as the promise of AI and the threats of active shooters grow.  One company, Aegis AI, is being led...
Restaurant Security Manager Interview on May 06, 2019
Wright’s Gourmet House in Tampa, Florida has been around for over 50 years. During most of that time, there were no security measures in place. Now...
Ranking Manufacturer Favorability 2019 on May 06, 2019
24 manufacturer's favorability was ranked based on 170+ integrators feedback. Voting plus in-depth comments revealed insights on which brands were...
Verkada Cloud VMS/Cameras Tested on May 02, 2019
Verkada is arguably the most ambitious video surveillance startup in many years. The company is developing their own cameras, their own VMS, their...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Access Control Job Walk Guide on May 22, 2019
Significant money can be saved and problems avoided with an access control job walk if you know what to look for and what to ask. By inviting...
ASCMA / Monitronics Declares Chapter 11 Bankruptcy on May 22, 2019
Monitronics is entering into Chapter 11 bankruptcy. The company, also called Ascent Capital Group Inc., aka ASCMA, aka Brinks Home Security,...
US Considers Sanctions Against Hikvision and Dahua on May 22, 2019
The US government is considering blacklisting "up to 5" PRC surveillance firms, including Hikvision and Dahua, Bloomberg reported, with human...
Dahua USA Celebrates 5 Years of Errors on May 21, 2019
Dahua USA is, in their own words, 'celebrating' 5 years in North America or as trade magazine SSN declared: Dahua Technology finds success in...
Axis ~$150 Outdoor Camera Tested on May 21, 2019
Axis has released the latest in their Companion camera line, the outdoor Companion Dome Mini LE, a 1080p integrated IR model aiming to compete with...
Covert Facial Recognition Using Axis and Amazon By NYTimes on May 20, 2019
What if you took a 33MP Axis camera covering one of the busiest parks in the US and ran Amazon Facial Recognition against it? That is what the...
Amazon Ring Public Subsidy Program Aims To Dominate Residential Security on May 20, 2019
Amazon dominates market after market. Quitely, but increasingly, they are doing so in residential security, through a combination of significant...
LifeSafety Power NetLink Vulnerabilities And Problematic Response on May 20, 2019
'Power supplies' are not devices that many think about when considering vulnerabilities but as more and more devices go 'online', the risks for...
Facial Recognition Systems Fail Simple Liveness Detection Test on May 17, 2019
Facial recognition is being widely promoted as a solution to physical access control but we were able to simply spoof 3 systems because they had no...
Inside Look Into Scam Market Research on May 17, 2019
Scam market research has exploded over the last few years becoming the most commonly cited 'statistics' for most industries, despite there clearly...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact