Bandwidth vs. Image Quality Shootout 2011

Author: Benros Emata, Published on Jul 23, 2011

When thinking about maximizing image quality, resolution is usually the first thing that comes to mind. However, resolution is not the only factor that impacts quality. The amount of bandwidth available and used can have a dramatic impact on image quality. In this report, we examine bandwidth and the effect that it has on quality across numerous cameras.

Which Image Quality is Better?

To better understand image quality, let's start by examining two samples of the same scene side by side:

Consider two questions:

  • Which camera has higher resolution? A or B?
  • Which camera is better? A or B?

It is pretty obvious that the image from Camera B is better so this should be a simple case.

The reality is that those images are from the same camera at the same resolution and frame rate (720p/30). All that was done to the camera was changing the Constant Bit Rate target from 512 Kb/s to 8 Mb/s.

Factors Impacting Quality

Even with the same resolution, two common settings impact quality:

  • Bit Rate: Most cameras can have their bit rate adjusted to specific levels (e.g., 512 Kb/s, 2 Mb/s, 8Mb/s, etc.)
  • Quantization Level: Most cameras can have the level of compression adjusted (often called a quality or compression setting with options from 1-10 or 0-100)

Typically, these are mutually exclusive. If you lock in bit rate, the camera will automatically adjust the quantization level to not exceed the bandwidth set. Vice versa, if you set the quantization level, the camera will automatically change the bandwidth consumed to make sure the quality / compression always stays at the same level.

Our Test Process

We wanted to better understand how changes in these two factors impact video quality. To do so, we did a series of tests with three HD cameras: the Axis P1344, the Sony CH140 and the Bosch NBN-921.

For the bandwidth tests, we tested each camera at the following levels:

  • 512 Kb/s
  • 1 Mb/s
  • 2 Mb/s
  • 4 Mb/s
  • 8 Mb/s

We did this across a series of scenes to see how quality would vary in different conditions:

  • Daytime Indoors (300 lux)
  • Nighttime Indoors (.5 lux)
  • Daytime Intersection

Finally, we did a similar series of tests varying the quality level of a VBR camera (the Axis across 0, 30, 60 and 100 levels) to better understand changes in quality and bandwidth consumption.

Questions We Considered

Here are the questions we considered and answered inside the report:

  • When changing bit rates, how much are image details impacted?
  • How much quality differences exist among manufacturers at the same bit rates?
  • How do manufacturer streaming methods differ? How does that impact quality and performance?
  • What is the 'optimal' bit rate to use?
  • When should you consider using higher bit rates?
  • When adjusting compression levels, how much does bandwidth consumption and image quality vary?
  • What is the 'right' compression level to use?

**** ******** ***** ********** ***** *******, ********** ** ******* *** first ***** **** ***** ** ****. *******, ********** ** *** the **** ****** **** ******* *******. *** ****** ** ********* available *** **** *** **** * ******** ****** ** ***** quality. ** **** ******, ** ******* ********* *** *** ****** that ** *** ** ******* ****** ******** *******.

Which ***** ******* ** ******?

** ****** ********** ***** *******, ***'* ***** ** ********* *** samples ** *** **** ***** **** ** ****:

******** *** *********:

  • ***** ****** *** ****** **********? * ** *?
  • ***** ****** ** ******? * ** *?

** ** ****** ******* **** *** ***** **** ****** * is ****** ** **** ****** ** * ****** ****.

*** ******* ** **** ***** ****** *** **** *** **** camera ** *** **** ********** *** ***** **** (****/**). *** that *** **** ** *** ****** *** ******** *** ******** Bit **** ****** **** *** **/* ** * **/*.

Factors ********* *******

**** **** *** **** **********, *** ****** ******** ****** *******:

  • *** ****: **** ******* *** **** ***** *** **** ******** ** specific ****** (*.*., *** **/*, * **/*, ***/*, ***.)
  • ************ *****: **** ******* *** **** *** ***** ** *********** ******** (often ****** * ******* ** *********** ******* **** ******* **** 1-10 ** *-***)

*********, ***** *** ******** *********. ** *** **** ** *** rate, *** ****** **** ************* ****** *** ************ ***** ** not ****** *** ********* ***. **** *****, ** *** *** the ************ *****, *** ****** **** ************* ****** *** ********* consumed ** **** **** *** ******* / *********** ****** ***** at *** **** *****.

Our **** *******

** ****** ** ****** ********** *** ******* ** ***** *** factors ****** ***** *******. ** ** **, ** *** * series ** ***** **** ***** ** *******: *** **** *****, the **** ***** *** *** ***** ***-***.

*** *** ********* *****, ** ****** **** ****** ** *** following ******:

  • *** **/*
  • * **/*
  • * **/*
  • * **/*
  • * **/*

** *** **** ****** * ****** ** ****** ** *** how ******* ***** **** ** ********* **********:

  • ******* ******* (*** ***)
  • ********* ******* (.* ***)
  • ******* ************

*******, ** *** * ******* ****** ** ***** ******* *** quality ***** ** * *** ****** (*** **** ****** *, 30, ** *** *** ******) ** ****** ********** ******* ** quality *** ********* ***********.

Questions ** **********

**** *** *** ********* ** ********** *** ******** ****** *** report:

  • **** ******** *** *****, *** **** *** ***** ******* ********?
  • *** **** ******* *********** ***** ***** ************* ** *** **** bit *****?
  • *** ** ************ ********* ******* ******? *** **** **** ****** quality *** ***********?
  • **** ** *** '*******' *** **** ** ***?
  • **** ****** *** ******** ***** ****** *** *****?
  • **** ********* *********** ******, *** **** **** ********* *********** *** image ******* ****?
  • **** ** *** '*****' *********** ***** ** ***?

[***************]

Key ******** *** ***************

  • *****, *******, ******* *********** ***** **** ********** ********* **** *** kb/s ** ***/* ****** *** ****/** *******. ***** ********************* ****** ******* ***/* *** * **/*.
  • ********* ***** ******* ****** ******* ** *** **** *** **** setting ** *** ******** ** ************* ****** ** *** **** adjust *** ****, ***** **** *** *********** ******.
  • ********* ********** ******* **** ** ** ***** ******* ****** ** low-light ******, ***** ***** ******* *** ******* ******* ** ******* light.
  • ********* ***** ** **** * ******* ****** ** ***** **** (i.e. ***** ****** **** ** ***** ******** ** *** ***)
  • ********* ******** * ******* ******** ****** ** ****** ******* ****** static ****.
  • ** ***** **** ********** ***-***** *** **** ** ******* ***** details, *** *** ***** ******** ** ** ** ** ***** high (*.*. ***** **** ***** ** *****). **** ** * large ***** **** ***** ************* ******** ****** ****.
  • ************** ** ***, *** ***** ********* *******, ****** ****** *** three *************. **** *** ********* *** ** ***** ** '****' in *****-****. ****'* *** *** ************, ******** ***** **** ** be ****** **. *****'* *** ******* ****** ***-***** ** **** modestly **** *** **** ******* ***-****. ***** ***** *****, ***********, be ****** **.
  • *** **** *** *********** ******, *** ******* ** ******** * good ******* ******* ********* *********** *** ***** *******. ***** *********** levels (*.*., *) ******** ********* ***********.

** ***** ** ***** ******** ** ********* *** *********:

  • *** ****/** *******, * **/* ***** ** ** *** '***** spot' ********* *******, ********* *** **** ******* *** ********* ***** across *** * *******.
  • ********** ********* *********** **** * **/* ** * **/* **** capture ******** **** ******* *** **** ******** ********* *********** ** 2TBs *** ***** *** * ************ ********* ********. *** **** users *** ******, **** ** ****** *** ***** *** ****.
  • ** * **** ******* *****-**** ** *******, ******** ******* **** support * **** '************' *** ************** (*.*. *** **** ***** or ***** ***-***). *** **** *****'* *** **************, *.*., *** drop ******.
  • ** ********** ***** ******* ****** **** *** ** **** *** concern ******** ***
  • ******** *** ** ****** ********* ***-***** ** ******* ******** ********* spikes
  • ** ***** *** ** ****** ********* ***-***** ** ** **** surveillance (**** ***-***** *** ****-*** ***** ** ***), ******** * slight ** ******** ******** ** *********** ****** ** ******** *** degree ** ********* ******. **** ******** ******** *** **** ***/** increasing ********.

Why **** ********* ****** *******?

****** **** **** ********* *******:

**** ******* *** **** *** ********** *** ***** **** **** not **** **** *** ********* ** ******* **** ****** ********. These *** **** ******* ******* *** ****** *** *** **** automatically ****** *** ****** ** *********** (** ****** *******).

********* #*:

*** **** ******* *** *****, *** **** ********* ** ***** to ****** *** *****. ** *** ** *** **** ****** bandwidth, ******* **** ****** - ******. **** ******** ** *** visible *** ******* ********* **** **.

********* #*:

*** **** ******* *** ******** ** *** *****, *** **** complex *** ***** **. **** ***** ** **** ****** ******* through *** *****, ****** ******* ** *** ****, **** ******* or **** ******* ***** ** *** *****. *** ******** ***** is ******** * ****** ** * ***** ****. *** ** any ** ***** ***** ******* *** ********** **** **. **** complexity, **** ********* ** ******.

********* #*:

**** **** *** ********** *** ***** **** ***, *** ****** must *** * ******** *********** *****. **** ***** ***** ******* intuitive *** ** ** *** ****. ***********, **** ** ******* called************. *********, ** ** ******** ** ** *** ****** ******* factor. **** ***** **** *** '*****' *** ***********. **** ****** in ******* ****** (*****, ****-*, ****, ***.). *.*** *** * ***** ******* **** 0 ** ** **** * ***** ******* *********** *** ** being ******* *********** (*******: *************** *** ***** **** *****).

********* #*:

*** **** ********* ********* *** *** **** ******* *** *****, the **** ******* **** ** ** ******* (*.*., *** ****** the *********** *****). ***'* **** ** **** ** ******:

**** ******* ** **** *****, ****** *** *********:

  • *** ** ****** ******* ******, *** ****** ** *********** / quantization********. *** ****** *** ******, *** **** ******* ***** *******.
  • *** ***** ** ********* ********* (**** **** **** ***).
  • ** *** ********* *****, *** *** ** ****** *** *** intersection **** *** ****** **** ******* *** ************ ** * more ******* ***** (******* **** *** ***** ** ****).
  • ** ********* *********, *** ***** *** ****** ******* ******** (**** carefully ** *** ****** ****** ********).

*** *** ******** *** ***** ******* **** **** *** *******. Export **** **** **** *** *** *** ******* **** ************. ** **** *** ****** **** *** ** *** ** help *** ********** **** ** ***** ** *** *** ********** the ***** **.

Optimizing *** *** *** ** ****, *****, *** ****

** **** ***** ** ******* *** ** ******** *** *** VBR ******** ****** *** *** ********** ** *** ***** ******* used ** *** *****. *** ***** ** ****** ***** *** group, ******* ** ******** **** * *** *** *** ******. One *** ***** ** **** ** **** *** *****'* *** implementation **** *** ***** *****-***** ** ** ***** ** ****** in. ** ******** **** *** ***-*** *** ***** *** ******* will **** ** * ********* *****-****. ** *** **** ******* of *** ***** ** ******* *** ***** ******* ** ****** to *********** *** ********* ************ ** ***** ************/***** ******** *** implementations.

CBR ***** ******* ******** (**** *****)

** **** ********* ** ******* *** **** *****'* ***** ******* at **** ********* *** ***-***** (*.*, *, *, *, *** 8****) ****** ***** ********* ****** (****** ***-*****, ****** *******, *** busy ************). ****** *** ********* ****** ** ****** ****** *********** in ******. *** ****** ** ********** ** ***** ** *** image ** ******* *** ********* *** ****** ***********.

*** *****'* *** **** *** **** ********** ** ******** ***-***** close ** *** **** ******* ***-*****: *) ***** ******; *) increase ***********. *** ****** ** **** *** ******** ** ****** operate ***** **** ****** ***** ** *****. *** **** ***********, image ******* **** **** ** **** **** ****** *** ******** of **** ******* *** **** ******** ** ***** *** *************** (e.g. **** ***** *** ***** ***-***), ******* *** ***** ****** for *** ********** ** ****** ** **** ** ********** *** compression *****.

** *** ***-***** ******** *********** ********* *** ***** ********** ** 512kbps *** ***** *** ***** ** ***** ** ** ***** and ******. *******, *** ********* ****** ** ********** ***-***** ** quite ******* ** *** *****'* ***-******* ******** ******* * ********** low ***** ***** ** ********* ***** *******.

** *** ****** ******* ********, *********** ********* ******** ******** ** the ***-**** *********. *******, ** **** ****-*** *** ********** ****** FoV *** ********** ******* *** ** ****** ********* *********** ** the ********* ***** **. ************, * ******* ** ******** ***-**** and *** ** ******* ** *** ***** *****, ***** ********** increases ** **** ******* *** ****, ****** ** ** ****** in *****-****, *** ****** ******* ** *** ****** ***-**** *** image *******.

** *** ****** ********** ************ *****, *** **** ******* ******* is ******** ** ********** ********* ** **** ******* *** **** are *********. *******, * ******** ******* ** ******** ***-**** *** resulting ***** ******* ***** ** *** ****** **** ******* ***** is ****** **** ** **** **** ******* ***. ******, * fairly ********** *********** ***** ****** **** *** ***** ** ***** mark.

CBR ***** ******* ******** (***** ***-***)

** **** ********* ** ******* *** ***** ***-***'* ***** ******* at **** ********* *** ***-***** (*.*, *, *, *, *** 8****) ****** ***** ********* ****** (****** ***-*****, ****** *******, *** busy ************). ****** *** ********* ****** ** ****** ****** *********** in ******. *** ****** ** ********** ** ***** ** *** image ** ******* *** ********* *** ****** ***********.

** *** ***-*** ** ******* ***, *** ***** ***-*** ******** considerably **** *********** ********* **** *** **** ***** **** ** the **** ******* *****. *******, **** ** ******** ** *** NBN-921 ********* **** ****** ***** ***** **********, *** ****** *********** on ********* ** *********** ***** ** **** ***** *** ***.

******* *** ***-***'* ******* ******** ** */***, ****** *** ***** to ****** ************ ***** *** ******* ***-***** ********** (~*.* ***). As **** ****** ** ** ********* *********** *** ******** ******* the ********* *** ***-**** **** ** **** ********** ***********.

** *** ****** ******* ********, *********** ********* *** ******* ******* at *** ******* *** ***** ***. ** *** ***** *****, compression ********* *** ******* *** ****** *******, *** ***** ******* to * ****** *** *** ****/*** **** ** ** ******. Despite ******** ***-***** ********** ** **** ** *** ***** *** 8mbps ****, *** ***** ******* ***** ** *******, **** ****** to ** **** ** ****** *** *** ********** ********* ********.

********* *** '**********' *** ******* ******** ** *** ******* **** in *** ******* ************ *****. *********, *** ******** ***-**** ** only ~*******. *** ***** ***** ****** ** ****** ************ *** manifests ** ****** ***-**** (*.******) **** **** ******* ** *** user ******* ***. ***** ******* ******** ** **** ********** **** towards *****. ***** **** * ** ************* ****** ********** ******** ************ ** *** *****.

CBR ***** ******* ******** (**** **-***)

** **** ********* ** ******* *** **** *****'* ***** ******* at **** ********* *** ***-***** (*.*, *, *, *, *** 8****) ****** ***** ********* ****** (****** ***-*****, ****** *******, *** busy ************). ****** *** ********* ****** ** ****** ****** *********** in ******. *** ****** ** ********** ** ***** ** *** image ** ******* *** ********* *** ****** ***********.

** *** ***-***** *********** *********, *** ********* ****** ** ********** bit-rates ** ***** ******* ** *** *****'* ***-******* ******** ******* a ********** *** ***** ***** ** ********* ***** *******.

** *** ****** ******* ********, *********** ********* ******* ***** ********** until *** ***** ****. ******** **** ******** ** ******** ******** at **** **** ******* ***** *** *****, *** ********* ****** is ***** ******* ** **** ****** ***.

** *** **** ******* ************ ********, ** *** ******* **** the ****** ** ***** ********* ** ~******* (~**% ***** *** user ******* ***). *** ***** ** ***** ***** '******' *** clears ** ****** ********** ** *** ***** *** ***** ****. Unlike *** ****** ****, *******, ***** ** ***** ***** * reduction ** *********** ********* ***** **** * ** *****.

VBR ***** ******* ******** (**** *****)

** **** ********* ** ******* *** **** *****'* ***** ******* at **** ********* *** *********** ****** (*, **, ** *** 100) ****** ***** ********* ****** (****** ***-*****, ****** *******, *** busy ************). ** ** *** **** ******* *****. ***** ******* means **** *********** (*.*., *) ***** ******* ******* **** **** compression (*.*., **, ***).

****** *** ********* ****** ** ****** ****** *********** ** ******. The ****** ** ********** ** ***** ** *** ***** ** enlarge *** ********* *** ****** ***********.

** *** ***-***** ********, *** *, ** *** ** *********** levels ****** ** ****** ** *********** ***** *******. *** *** point ** ******* ** *** ********* *********** ** ********* ***********. Notably *** * *********** ***** ******* ** ** ************ **** ~24mbps; ********** *********** ** ** ***** ******* ** ** ********** ~12mbps *********. ** ** * **** ********** ~*.***** ** *******. Thus, ***** **** * * ** ** *********** ***** ******* in ****** ******* ****, *** ******* ********* *********** ** ~**%.

** *** ****** ******* ********, *** * ** ** *********** change ******* ** *** **** *********** ********* **** (~**%) **** little **** ** ******* ******* ** *** *****.

*** ************ ******** *** **** ******** ** *** ****** ******* (0 ** ** ******* ** ~**% ********* ******* **** ****** loss ** ***** *******).

** ** ********* ** **** **** *** '*****-****' *** ***-***** and ******-*******/************ *** ** ** ********* *********** ****** (~** *** low-light, *** ~** *** ******-*******/************). ************ **** **** ** ********** and ******** *** ******* ** **** ******* *** ******* * more ********** ************ ********.

***** ** * ***** ** *** *****'* *********** ***** **. Bandwidth (* ******):

*** *** ******** **** ** **** *** **** *********** **** in ********* *** *** *** ****-*** ****** (****** ******* *** intersection) ****** **** * ** ** ***********, ***** *** ***-***** curve ********* ** * ******** ******* - *** ****** ********** until *** *** *********** *****. *** *** '****-***' ****** ******** to * ******** ******* (* ********** ******* ** ~*.*****) ** *** ** *********** *****.

***** ** ** ************* ** **** ***** * ****** ******* a ******* ** ***** ***** ****** ********** *** *** *** find * **********, *.*. ** *** ** ***** ** ***********. Of ****** ********** *** **** ***/** ********** *** ******** *** also **** ******** ********* ****** ** *** ***-***** ***********, ** well.

***********

******* **** ********** ** */*** ******* ******** *******. **** ****** lens *** ******** ** ******* * ******* **** *** ******** (lens ***** ~*********).

**** *** *** ******* **** ** '******* **. *********' *****:

  • **** *****(****** $***) - **** */*; */*" ****; **.* ******** ; 0.3/0.05 *** (*****/**)
  • ***** ***-***(****** $***) - **** */*; */*" ***; **.* *****; *.*/*.* Lux (*****/**)
  • **** *****(****** $***) - **** */*; */*" ****; **.* *******; *.* Lux (**)

** *** *** *******, *** ***** ******* ******** *** **** scene ** * ***** **** ******* *** ***-****. *** ***** was ******** *** **** ** **** ********* *** ***-***** (*******, 1mbps, *****, *****, *** *****). **** ****** ***-***** *** *** were ********** *** ********.

** *** *** *******, **** *** ***** *** ****. *** same ***** ******* ****** **** ** *** ******* **** ********. Each ***** *** ******** ** **** ** **** *********** ***** settings (*, **, **, *** ***).

**** *** ***** *** ******* ***/*** ********:

  • **** ***** - *** ** * *********** ** ** (* - ***)
  • ***** ***-*** - *** **** * ****** ** **** **** and * ******* ** ***** ****
  • **** ***** - *** **** * ******* ** *****
Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

48MP 180 Camera (Digital Watchdog) Test on May 10, 2017
Camera resolution continues to advance, with Digital Watchdog offering the MegaPIX PANO 48MP 180° camera, the highest resolution mainstream camera...
Last Day - IP Networking Course May 2017 on Apr 26, 2017
Today is the last day to register for the May IP Networking Course. This is the only networking course designed specifically for video...
Hanwha Lowest Cost WiseNet X Camera (XND-6010) Tested on Apr 13, 2017
IPVM bought and tested the lowest-cost WiseNet X model, the indoor 2MP fixed focal XND-6010 dome, continuing our testing of Hanwha's new WiseNet X...
Pelco Surevision 3 Tested on Apr 12, 2017
Pelco has released generation 3 of its Surevision cameras, claiming improved performance in both super low light and WDR performance. We bought...
Dahua Backdoor Uncovered on Mar 06, 2017
A major cyber security vulnerability across many Dahua products has been discovered by an independent researcher, reported on IPVM, verified by...
TVI 4.0 Doubles HD Analog Bandwidth on Mar 05, 2017
HD analog's move up market continues. Starting a few years ago at just 720p, HD analog is now poised for 4K and beyond. Techpoint, the company...
20 Manufacturer Favorability Ranked on Feb 28, 2017
20 security industry organizations' favorability was ranked based on direct feedback from over 100 integrators. In-depth comments revealed insights...
'Dirty': Hikvision Attacks Genetec on Feb 20, 2017
Hikvision is angry at the growing public awareness that Hikvision is owned by the Chinese government. They took aim at Genetec,...
Arecont Vision MicroDome Duo Tested on Feb 14, 2017
Arecont Vision is back with another multi-head camera, this time thinking smaller with the MicroDome Duo, a two-imager model, with the tagline...
Camera Course Winter 2017 on Feb 02, 2017
Learn video surveillance and get certified. IPVM provides live online classes, recorded videos, personal help, cutting edge education and...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Pelco Shutting Down Clovis Line, Laying Off 200 on May 22, 2017
Pelco's Clovis facility once turned out some of the industry's most popular products. Now, the facility is mostly building "obsolete" equipment,...
IP Camera - 15 Year Shootout on May 22, 2017
How far have IP cameras come? We bought and tested 4 cameras across the past 15 years to understand how much and where performance has...
Remote Video Monitoring Providers Directory on May 21, 2017
Remote video monitoring can help integrators generate RMR plus end users lower their security costs and/or improve response to critical...
Axis Criticizes OEMs: "When You Buy An Axis Camera, An Axis Camera Is What You Get!" on May 19, 2017
When you buy a Honeywell camera, you likely get a Hikvision, Dahua or some other company's product. The same goes for easily 100 different...
Hackable 125kHz Access Control Migration Guide on May 19, 2017
Despite being one of the most popular credentials, 125 kHz credentials are easily copied and insecure as we showed in our test results, video...
Forget The Backdoor, "ALL HIKVISION PRODUCTS" On Sale on May 18, 2017
Less than 2 weeks after the Hikvision Backdoor was confirmed, Hikvision has launched a sale "ON ALL HIKVISION PRODUCTS". In this note, we examine...
Amazon Techs Installing IP Cameras Tested on May 18, 2017
In 2015, Amazon started offering video surveillance installation. Now, Amazon has made it a lot easier, with automatic add-on options and...
Hanwha Recorder Vulnerability Analyzed on May 18, 2017
ICS-CERT has released a vulnerability notice for Hanwha SRN-4000 recorders.  Hanwha provided additional information to IPVM about this issue,...
DMP Video Doorbell / Access Reader Examined on May 17, 2017
Consumers increasingly demand video doorbells, with "doorbells selling like hotcakes, everyone wants a doorbell", according to ADT's CEO. At ISC...
ShotSpotter To IPO, Facing Low Revenue and Losses on May 17, 2017
A rare event for North American security manufacturers is upcoming. ShotSpotter is planning to IPO on the NASDAQ, aiming to raise $34.5...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact