Awards assist manufacturers in selling products rather than identifying the best solutions for user's needs.
This is a growing concern as the number of awards are increasing substantially. This month [September 2009], both ASIS and Security Products jump into the awards game.
General Problems with Awards
A number of important problems with awards should be recognized:
- Judging criteria is vague or non-existent (judges can choose whatever they think is 'best')
- No testing of the actual products are performed
- Information used to judge is limited to data sheets and marketing materials
- Entrance is often constrained to those willing to pay the fees or buy a booth at the exhibit
- No information is ever provided on why the awardee won and the other participants did not
Vendors submit basic product information and answer 4 questions. Judges review the submissions and then pick winners.
While the submission fee is only $250 USD, only exhibitors may enter (which usually a minimum of $8,000 USD for a booth) [see entrance rules
ASIS states this benefits security professionals by helping them identify new and innovative offerings. Certainly, the mission of ASIS
is to increase "the effectiveness and productivity of security professionals." However, how does limiting awards to only exhibitors help security professionals?
And where is the public explanation of why these companies were selected and others were not? Just a list of companies
? Would not security professionals benefit from greater information and details on strengths and weaknesses?
Security Product Magazine Awards
Security Products is running a "Product of the Year"
awards program. In this program, there are 7 award categories [see entrance form
]. [Update 9/16: An earlier version stated that there were 43 categories based on an e-mail I received from Security Products. In a new message, Security Products states there are only 7].
The Security Prodcut "awards will be given at the discretion of the judges" without any criteria provided.
In its media kit
, Security Products clearly states their objective is to be, "the marketing partner that [vendors] can depend on to help generate leads and increase sales." With so many awards and such little objective criteria, this program accomplishes that.
Integrators and Users Must Speak Out
These programs exist because they can take advantage of the trust that people have in the honesty of others.
If each of you raises questions or objections when manufacturers brag about these awards, these awards will go away. Nothing motivates manufacturers more than the fear of losing business.
We Need Meaningful Awards
Awards can be useful if they measure criteria that are meaningful to users. For instance, best camera in low light (measured at a specific lux level, F stop, object reflexivity, etc.) or best tripwire detection (measured based on FAR, FRR, ROC, etc. in specific weather, lighting and environmental condiitons).
Measure what's meaningful and publish the details so everyone can see and verify.
Until we do this, we are basically choosing the fastest swimmer by looking at photos of people in their underwear.
Deceptive ASIS Attendance
on Oct 06, 2017
ASIS is being deceptive with its conference reporting, effectively inflating the event's real actual attendance.
What they try, but struggle to...
Troubles At Arecont Vision
on Oct 03, 2017
Arecont is facing big problems.
But Arecont says the future is 'bright'.
In this note, we share feedback from Arecont and from sources close to...
Vivotek Delta Acquisition Concludes
on Oct 02, 2017
On August 8, 2017, Delta Group made an offer to acquire Vivotek.
Now, the acquisition process has concluded.
Inside this note, we examine the...
ASIS 2017 Stronger, Says Manufacturers
on Sep 29, 2017
ASIS has reversed a trend of declining satisfaction from manufacturers, based on results of our survey of 80 manufacturers.
ASIS Show 2017 Final Report
on Sep 27, 2017
ASIS is in Dallas for 2017 and this is our final show report (compare to our 2016 ASIS show report).
When walking in, one is greeted with Dahua's...
Avigilon Touting 'Made In America'
on Sep 18, 2017
Canadian manufacturer Avigilon, who completed a US manufacturing facility in 2015, is now running a marketing campaign touting 'Made In America',...
Cloud Guy Prints Book, Misses Irony
on Sep 15, 2017
On-premise security systems are dead.
But $75 print books are alive and well.
Such are the lessons from Brivo's CEO new book "The Five...
Most Recent Industry Reports
Buy From B&H, Ship Direct From ADI
on Oct 16, 2017
B&H, one of the largest online sellers of video surveillance equipment to end users, regularly purchases their video surveillance equipment...
Competing Against Siemens
on Oct 16, 2017
Siemens entered the integration business with 15,000+ customers, through their acquisition of Security Technologies Group in 2001. Since that time,...
Geovision GV-EDR2100 Tested Vs Hikvision
on Oct 16, 2017
A number of ADI's top selling IP cameras are, at least surprisingly to us, from Geovision.
We recently bought and tested the Geovision EDR2100...
Exacq M Series Low Cost NVR Tested
on Oct 12, 2017
With recent cyber security issues hitting NVRs and cameras from low cost leaders Dahua and Hikvision, users are increasingly seeking alternatives...
PoE Powered Access Control Tutorial
on Oct 12, 2017
Powering access control with Power over Ethernet, like for IP cameras, has become increasingly common.
However, the demands for access power are...