Analog vs HD Night Shootout

By: Benros Emata, Published on Mar 26, 2011

The whole point of megapixel is better image quality but what if megapixel was actually worse than analog at night? In the consumer world, maybe this is acceptable but in surveillance, most cameras need to 'see' 24 / 7.

[WARNING: This report is OUT OF DATE and should only be used for historical review. Megapixel / HD camera low light performance has improved significantly since 2011. See: Ranking IP Camera Low Light Performance]

In this report, we share our test results of head to head comparisons between analog, SD IP and Megapixel cameras. We asked a number of analog centric integrators, including the folks at CCTVForum.com, for their recommendations on their favorite analog cameras for use in low light scenes. Based on their recommendations, we bought a Bosch Dinion [link no longer available] and CNB Mona Lisa and set them up side by side with megapixel cameras from our previous tests. We then tested them in a series of real world scenes.

Here is a preview of our test :

Inside the Pro section, we dig through the tradeoffs and key findings revealed in the tests. For background, make sure you understand the issues in exposure setting adjustments that we explained in detail in our 'How Exposure Impacts Low Light Surveillance.'

Key Findings

We note 3 key findings:

  • In a parking lot lit with street lamps (3 to 5 lux), megapixel cameras provided only minimal improvements in image detail over analog - far less than the number of pixels would expect to provide.
  • In a field with no direct street lamps and only ambient light (~0.5 lux), analog cameras provided far more detail than the megapixel ones. The analog cameras provided outlines of human subjects at a 32 ft width FoV while the megapixel cameras were so dark that it was almost impossible to make out the human subjects.
  • In under 1 lux scenes, the only way the megapixel cameras could provide similar image detail as the analog cameras was to significantly lengthen the exposure setting. However, of course, this increase motion blur - a major negative tradeoff.

In the video below, we show the key findings by analyzing the recorded test samples:

Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News
Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News

Recommendations

With these key findings recognized, here are our recommendations:

  • Using megapixel in an outdoor scene with street lighting is likely still superior to analog (or SD IP). At night, minimal benefits are gained and during the day, significant benefits can be achieved. However, at night, megapixel cameras essentially waste bandwidth. If possible with one's VMS system, consider dropping the resolution level during the night.
  • Using megapixel in a scene with no direct lighting at night is problematic. If the scene must be surveilled in these conditions, either (1) lengthen the shutter, (2) add IR illumination or (3) use SD instead of megapixel. All of these have important drawbacks. Do not lengthen the shutter beyond 1/8s if you need to capture clear details of moving subjects (i.e., if you are not confident that an intruder will stop in the scene). Use integrated IR only if the subject is close to the camera (less than 40 feet). Otherwise, use add on IR (though expect to pay an additional $300+). [Note: for more, see our IR comparison report.] Finally, use SD only if you can accept less detail or the use of more cameras during the day.

Video Clips Download (ZIP File)

Review our Analog vs Megapixel Sample videos zip file [link no longer available] (~230 MB) containing all the video clips and images generated during our testing. The clips are embedded inside an ExacqVision player and simply needs to be double clicked to view. In the Exacq player's Options menu we recommend enabling 'Show Camera Names' to show the names of the cameras on-screen.

The clips and images are from our Outdoor test (presented in this report) and Indoor (preliminary) tests as well as alternative setting tests.

Methodology

Three (3) Standard Definition, and two (2) Megapixel cameras are included in our low-light performance testing.

Standard Definition Cameras:

  • CNB BBM-24F - 1/3" CCD; F1.0 Computar; 600TVL (650TVL B/W); 0.005 Lux (B/W); online $120
  • Bosch LTC0498 [link no longer available] - 1/3" CCD; F1.0 Computar; 540TVL; 0.98 Lux (100 IRE, B/W); online $400
  • Bosch NBN-498-21P [link no longer available] - 1/3" CCD; F1.3 Bosch, 4CIF (704x480); 0.98 Lux (100 IRE, B/W); online $700

Megapixel Cameras (IP):

  • Sanyo HD4000 [link no longer available] - 1/2.5" CMOS; F1.8 integrated lens; 1920x1080; 0.1 Lux (F1.8, b/w, gain: High); online $950
  • Pelco Sarix IXE20DN [link no longer available] - 1/3" CMOS; F1.2 Pelco; 1280x720; 0.25 Lux (Mono, 33 ms); online $1,300

All SD cameras were analog, except for the Bosch NBN-498. A Sony SNTEP104 encoder was used to stream the analog cameras to our ExacqVision VMS. During testing default settings were used on the Sony encoder including a 720x480 resolution. The two MP cameras were configured for 720p resolution during all tests.

 

Here are the key default settings relevant to low light performance for each camera:

  • CNB BBM-24F - 1/60s shutter; AGC on '15'
  • Bosch LTC0498 - 1/60s shutter; SensUp 4x; AGC on '15'
  • Bosch NBN-498-21P -  1/60s shutter; SensUp 4x; AGC on '15'
  • Sanyo HD4000 - 1/30s shutter; AGC on 'normal'
  • Pelco Sarix IXE20DN - 1/8s shutter; (no gain setting in interface)

In the video below we examine each camera's admin interface focusing on exposure and gain settings, showing the defaults and available ranges for these low-light optimizations.

Scenarios/Applications

Two (2) nighttime/low-light test scenarios were devised that correspond to 'real-world' video surveillance applications:

  • Artificially Lit Area (Parking Lot); 3 to 5 Lux
  • No Light (Open Field) Area; ~0.5 Lux

In both primary scenarios two human subjects provide various examples of motion. The human subjects are positioned at a location within scene corresponding to a 32 foot wide FoV. As such the SD cameras provided roughly 20 pixels/ft. and the MP cameras provided roughly double the SD or 40 pix/ft. at the human subjects.

Tests

In the first Parking Lot scenario two (2) key tests were performed:

  • All 5 test cameras at default shutter and gain settings. This meant that the SD cameras had either 1/30s or 1/60s shutter speeds, the MP Sanyo had 1/30s and the MP Pelco had 1/8s shutter speeds.
  • MP Pelco camera configured for 1/30s shutter speed to normalize with the default 1/30s or 1/60s shutter speeds of the SD cameras.

The Open Field scenario featured four (4) key tests:

  • All 5 test cameras at default shutter and gain settings. This meant that the SD cameras had either 1/30s or 1/60s shutter speeds, the MP Sanyo had 1/30s and the MP Pelco had 1/8s shutter speeds.
  • MP Pelco camera configured for 1/30s shutter speed to normalize with the default 1/30s or 1/60s shutter speeds of the SD cameras.
  • MP Pelco camera configured for 1/250s shutter speed
  • MP Pelco camera configured for 1/500s shutter speed

We considered other MP cameras as well. For example, we considered the Axis 5MP P1347, and the Sony HD CH140. Due to various technical issues we decided to exclude them from our main study. However, it is key to note that their low-light performance levels were similar to the Sanyo and Pelco MP cameras included in the 'main' study.

Testing Issues

The Sanyo HD4000 featured in this report presented several issues during our testing and analysis. The first issue involved an inability to set the correct time on the camera. This became an issue when searching its archived video on our Exacqvision VMS. According to Exacq this is a potential problem when cameras and VMSes are not synced up, since the VMS will try to 'honor' the camera's time setting.  Because of this issue we could not export clips from Sanyo along with the other cameras in synchronous mode.

Another issue we faced with the Sanyo HD4000 was the inability to configure a slow shutter setting. Sanyo calls this a 'long' shutter, and it is a feature of the HD4000. However, we had difficulty in configuring the 'long' shutter setting reliably and excluded it from the study. Thus, the default setting of 1/30s was used throughout all tests.

If cameras shipped with lenses we used them in testing as it represents what users are likely to use in real world scenarios. The three IP cameras shipped with lenses, while the two analog cameras not coming with lenses were fitted with separately purchased Computar (F1.0, AI, varifocal) lenses.

5 reports cite this report:

Multi-Megapixel Deployment Statistics on Jan 01, 2012
Megapixel camera resolution increases regularly, with manufacturers pushing higher and higher resolutions all the time. 2011 saw the introduction...
Directory of Camera Shootout Series on Dec 27, 2011
The following directory lists all of our camera shootouts. These shootouts pit 4 - 8 different surveillance cameras in simultaneous tests on real...
CNB Network Camera Review on Sep 08, 2011
Korean surveillance manufacturer CNB has historically been one of the more popular analog brands for budget / low cost appliations, viewed as a...
ACTi's 4MP Price/Performance Analysis on Aug 30, 2011
Over the past year, Taiwanese megapixel manufacturer ACTi released a line of four-megapixel cameras, while discontinuing most of the standard...
Color Versus Day/Night Shootout on Apr 16, 2011
Most people prefer color over black and white but when it gets dark out, almost all surveillance experts agree that black and white video provides...
Comments : Members only. Login. or Join.

Related Reports

Startup Spectral Edge RGB+IR Claims "Unique Low Light Performance Tech" on Apr 03, 2019
This UK startup, born out of university research, is boldly proclaiming that they deliver "Unique low light performance tech for video surveillance...
Speco Ultra Intensifier Tested on Apr 22, 2019
While ISC West 2019 named Speco's Ultra Intensifier the best new "Video Surveillance Cameras IP", IPVM testing shows the camera suffers from...
The Embarrassing Story of ISC West's Best New IP Camera on Apr 24, 2019
A sad but simple situation: Only 2 companies paid SIA the thousands of dollars required to compete for the best new 'cameras IP' The judges...
Hikvision ColorVu Camera Tested on Jun 24, 2019
Hikvision says their new ColorVu line captures "vivid chromatic images in darkness", with unconventional white light illuminations whereas most...
Lens Iris Tutorial on Aug 08, 2019
Cameras, like humans, have irises, controlling the light which hits the imager and impacting image details. However, cameras have multiple types of...
Wide Dynamic Range (WDR) Guide on Oct 01, 2019
Understanding wide dynamic range (WDR) is critical to capturing high quality images in demanding conditions. However, with no real standards, any...
Hikvision ColorVu is Smart Marketing on Oct 03, 2019
Hikvision ColorVu (see IPVM test results) is smart marketing, a lesson to be learned by competitors and a rising trend. Inside this note, we...
Integrated IR Camera Usage Statistics 2019 on Oct 21, 2019
Virtually every IP camera now comes with integrated IR but how many actually make use of IR or choose 'super' low light cameras without IR? In...
Biggest Low Light Problems 2019 on Nov 08, 2019
Over 150 integrators responded to our survey question: "What are the biggest problems you face getting good low-light images?" Inside, we share...
Budget Covert Cameras Tested on Nov 26, 2019
Covert cameras under $100 are widely available online but are they any good? To see how these models really work in the real world, we bought...

Most Recent Industry Reports

IronYun AI Analytics Tested on Feb 17, 2020
Taiwan startup IronYun has raised tens of millions for its "mission to be the leading Artificial Intelligence, big data video software as a service...
Access Control ADA and Disability Laws Tutorial on Feb 17, 2020
Safe access control is paramount, especially for those with disabilities. Most countries have codes to mandate safe building access for those...
ISC West 2020 Removes China Pavilion, No Plans To Cancel Or Postpone on Feb 17, 2020
ISC West plans to go on next month, amidst concerns over coronavirus. However, the Asia / China Pavilion has been removed, show organizers...
Hanwha Wisenet X Plus PTRZ Tested on Feb 14, 2020
Hanwha has released their PTRZ camera, the Wisenet X Plus XNV-6081Z, claiming the "modular design allows for easy installation". We bought and...
IPVM Conference 2020 on Feb 13, 2020
IPVM is excited to announce our 2020 conference. This is the first and only industry event that will be 100% sponsor-free. Like IPVM online, the...
Bosch Dropping Dahua on Feb 13, 2020
Bosch has confirmed to IPVM that it is in the process of dropping Dahua, over the next year, as both IP camera contract manufacturer and recorder...
BluB0X Alleges Lenel, S2, Software House Are Dinosaurs on Feb 13, 2020
BluB0X is running an ad campaign labeling Lenel, S2, Software House, Honeywell, AMAG and more as dinosaurs: In a follow-up email to IPVM,...
London Live Police Face Recognition Visited on Feb 13, 2020
London police have officially begun using live facial recognition in select areas of the UK capital, sparking significant controversy. IPVM...
Converged vs Dedicated Networks For Surveillance Tutorial on Feb 12, 2020
Use the existing network or deploy a new one? This is a critical choice in designing video surveillance systems. Though 'convergence' was a big...