Alarm Panels - Canned vs Integrated

By: Ari Erenthal, Published on Feb 07, 2017

Alarm control panels generally come in one of two types:

  • Integrated alarm controllers, with controls and the keypad in the same device
  • Traditional 'canned' control panels

The advantages of 'canned' control panels typically include:

  • Room for accessories
  • Greater security
  • Ease of documentation
  • Longer battery life possible

By contrast, the advantages of integrated controllers generally are:

  • Faster to install
  • Neater wiring
  • More wireless options

Inside this post, we explain and contrast each of these points in detail.

***** ******* ****** ********* come ** *** ** two *****:

  • ********** ***** ***********, **** controls *** *** ****** in *** **** ******
  • *********** '******' ******* ******

*** ********** ** '******' control ****** ********* *******:

  • **** *** ***********
  • ******* ********
  • **** ** *************
  • ****** ******* **** ********

** ********, *** ********** of ********** *********** ********* are:

  • ****** ** *******
  • ****** ******
  • **** ******** *******

****** **** ****, ** explain *** ******** **** of ***** ****** ** detail.

[***************]

********** ***** *********** **** a ****** ******* ** the **** ** *** keypad *** *** *** wired *********** (**** ** power, *****, ********* *****, smoke *********, ***.) ** connect **, ** ***** below:

*********** ******* ****** ***** *** control ***** ** * metal ********* ****** ****, ***** ******* ** a ****** ** ***-**-***-*** location. *** ****** *** all *** ****** *******, including *** ******, ********** terminates ** *** ***, as ***** *****:

Control ****** *** **** ********

**** **** **** * lot ** ******** ***** space, ******** *** ********* to **** ******* *** connections, ** *** **** expanders ** ******, *** to *** ****** *********.  

** ******** ** **** knockouts **** ***** *** installer ** ***** ***** in **** *** **** of *** ****, ******* the ****, ******* ****** also ******* ******, ***, and **** *********. ***** allow ********** ** *** wires *** *** ***** along *** ******* ** the ****. **** **** use * */*" *********, allowing ********** ***** ***** ****** ******* conduit ** **** ******** *************. A ****** ***-***** ********* secures *** ******* ** the *** *** ** usually ********* ** ******** stores *** **** **** a ******. 

** ******* ** *** used, * ****-** ******* is ******** ***********. * snap-in ******* ** ****** a ******* **** **** prevents *** ***** **** rubbing ******* *** ***** sharp ***** ***** ** the ******** ****. ********** from ******* ******* ** construction ** ****** ***** settlement **** **** ***** to ***** ***** ** rub **** ****** ** short *** ******** ********, leading ** ************ ***** circuits ***** *** ********* to **** *** ********. This ** ********** ****** where **** ****** ***** the *** ******* *** same ********, ******* *** wires ** **** ****** against *** **** ** the ********. **** ******** ** to *** * ****-** bushing ** ***** ******** hole, ***, ** ********, to ****** *** **** bundles ******* ********* ** the ***** *** *** ****** too *******. ****-** ******** are ********* ** **** hardware ****** *** ********** supply ******, ***** *** ~$20 *** * *** of ***.  

Control ****** *** ********** **** ******

** ***** ** ** useful, **** ********** **** as ***** ******* **** be ****** **********. ******* the ****** **** ******** the ****** *** ***** alerts ** * ******* station ** * ****** accessible ***** ** ***** because **** ***** ** accessible ** ******, ********* intruders. Physically ********** *** ******* panel *** *** ****** allows *** ********* ** choose * **** **** will ** ******, ********* to ****, ** ****. Often, ******** **** ***** or ****** *** ***** keypad ** *** ******** belief **** ***** ** during *** ***** ****** **** prevent ** **** ******* a ******. ** *** control ***** ** ** the ****** **** ** in * ****** *******, it **** ******** ** send ******* *** ** long ** *** ******** continues ** *** *** door ******** *** ****** detectors. 

**** **** **** **** cam *****, ****** *** electronics **** ********* ** access. *** ***** **** be ***** ** ******* open ****** * ****** with ********* ****** *** disable *** *****. **** cans *** **** ** metal, ****** **** ******* even **** *********. ** high ******** ************, **** can **** ** ****** with ****** ********, ******* a ****** ** *** central ******* ******** *** can ** **** ** removed. 

Control ****** **** ************* ******

**** ******* ****** **** **** a ****** ******* ** the ****** ** *** *** door, ** ***** *****: 

********** ******** *** *****, such ** ****** ********, wire maps, ** ***** *********** specific ** *** ********, either ******* ** ****** on *** ****** ** the *** **** ** printed ** ****** **** inside *** ***. ***** things ******** ***** ** cans *** *********** *******, spare *********, ***** *****, and ***** ** ************ and *******. *** **** can ** ********** ** troubleshooters ** *** ******. 

Control ****** ***** *** ****** ******* ****** ****

******* *** *** *** more **** *** ***********, some ********** ****** ** offer * ****** ****** battery, ** **** ** a ****** ******* *** longer ****. 

Integrated *********** *** ****** ** *******

**** *** ***** ** built **** *** ******, the **** **** **** often ** ******* *** easier **** **** *** control ***** ** *** in *** ******** *********, far **** *** **** contact ** ********* *********. Integrated *********** *** ******** to ** ****** *** fast ** **** **, with ***** ******* *** add *** **** ******* ******.  

Integrated *********** *** ******** *****

**** ******* ****** ** not **** **** ******** receivers. ** ***** ** be ********** **** ******** devices, ********** **** ******** and ******* * ******** receiver ** *** *****. In ********, ********** *********** commonly have ******** ********* ***** in. *** ******* *** integrated ********** ** **** often ******* ** * central ********, ** *** a ****** ****** ** getting * **** ****** from * ******** ******. In ********, ******** ********** issues *** *** ******** when *** ******* ***** is ** * ******** or * ****** ****, forcing *** ********* ** try ** ***** *** wireless ******** ****** ** the ******** ******* *** then *** * **** from *** ******** ** the *****. 

**** ******* ************* **** proprietary ******** ********* **** only **** **** * small ***** ** ******** products, ***** **** ***** wireless ***** *******. ** contrast, ********** ********** ************* commonly **** **** * range ** *******, ********* Z-wave *** ******, ******** the ********* ** **** ***** home *** *** ******* as **** ** *********** alarm *******. 

Integrated *********** *** ****** *** ****** ** *******

**** ********** **** ****** to ****** *** ******** devices **** ********** ***********. The **** ***** **** will **** ** ** run ** *****, *****, telephone ** *** ******** does *** ****** *** communication, *** ******** *** or *** ***** *******. With ******** *********, *** length ** *** ***** and ***** **** **** can ** **** **** short ******. **** ***** it *** ****** *** new ********** ** ** trained ** ******* ** integrated ********** ******. ***** drilled *** ***** ****** are **** ** * minimum, ****** ** ****** to ***** *** ***** up **********. ****** ** an ********** ********** ****** can ***** ** ************ in *** ***** ** less, ******** * ****** technician ** ***** ******** ********* a ***. ** ********, wiring ** * ******* panel ** * ***** undertaking, *** ***** **** to ****** ***********, *** often ***** * **** portion ** * ***. 

Which ****** *** ******?

************* ********* ****** ** alarm ***** ** * can, ******* *** *** is * ********** **** to **** *******, ***** accessories, *** **** *************. However, ** ********** ****** is *** **** ********** in **** ************. ******* residential *************, ********** ************* primarily ***** ******** *******, are ****** *** ****** to ******** **** ********** systems, ***** ***** ** lower ***** *****. 

Comments (7)

Both serve their own purpose. When we install a security system in a commercial environment, we install one inside of a can. This provides more security and allows for hardwiring system components with better battery backup. If we're monitoring fire the communication equipment needs to be in a fire rated enclosure, you typically can't do this with an all-in-one system.

When we install a system in a home, we use the DMP XTLplus. We do not install systems like the 2GIG shown in the article because the siren and keypad give everything away. Smash that, and the criminal is good to go. They offer SMASH protection at alarm.com, but I wouldn't trust it. We like the XTLplus because it has z-wave, spread spectrum wireless, wifi and cellular communication, and the siren, keypad and control panel are all separate but still just as easy to install. 

One of the other big differences between the two styles is communication, typically all-in-one systems only have one path of communication, some have two. Multiple paths especially when monitoring fire is critical. We have a company policy always to install using two paths of communication, the network is primary and cellular is the backup. If they happen to have a POTS line we will plug that in as a third path.

Control panels in metal enclosures can get really messy really fast if the technician is trained to keep it clean. This can cause some serious issues down the road. One of the many reasons we don't offer as much hardwiring in homes anymore. 

Yeah, wiring is a lost art. I had a job where I would go from site to site and wire and program the panel. This company had a rough-in crew for running wires with the walls open and a finishing crew for wiring up windows and installing sensors. But terminating the panel, making splices, labeling and documenting everything, and doing the programming is easy to screw up and hard to do right.  

I seldom use the integrated systems, but sometimes it's the best option in residential with slab floors, no attic and customers who prefer fast installation with no, or very little, drilling/fishing.

In commercial, I like to use Honeywell Vista-ULKT, a larger cabinet with heavy gauge metal, tampered, which can easily accommodate extra modules and batteries. But, I've used the regular can in commercial jobs too. Never used an integrated system in commercial, don't think it would be prudent to do so.

 

Interesting. Do you use the the Vista-ULKT in order to qualify for UL, or just because?

I use the Vista-ULKT just because....not to qualify for UL. I installed one in my home and the homes of quite a few customers. My reason for this is to enhance security by further protecting the alarm panel and, in some cases, the GSMX4G within the enclosure. I've taken over accounts where the panel was located in a closet near a front door, with the keypad next to the closet door. I think this is too close to a delay zone giving someone too much time to tamper or destroy the panel. So, I might use the UL can for that install. I've seen a few burglary scenes where the flimsy can was compromised to silence the system. The UL can will slow them down as it is thicker gauge metal.

The other reason I use the UL can is for it's capacity to accommodate extra modules and batteries when required.

I generally try to stay as far away as I can from integrated systems.  The whole point of a security system is security, after all.  I've seen one too many lick-and-stick systems defeated with a $10 hammer.  However, when you're trying to sell someone a DSC NEO panel with a wire-free keypad, because a wire simply cannot be run, and someone else is competing against you with a Simon XTi, it is imperative to demonstrate to the client why a professional company installs a "canned" system over an integrated one.  I'll never beat their price, but I can sell the reliability and security of my product any day, provided the client can see value in what I'm offering.  Unfortunately, in this cell-phone-market industry we live in where people expect the flashiest equipment for $0 down and an upgrade every 2 to 3 years, it can be hard to sell quality...

Ari - Just so you'll know: the industry term for what you're calling an integrated system is "Self-Contained" System, I guess because the brains/control and battery are just attached to the back of a keypad making a single unit.

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Resideo AlarmNet Has Major Outage on Mar 12, 2020
AlarmNet suffered a major outage yesterday, impacting Total Connect, Resideo, and Honeywell / Ademco alarm customers. Inside we examine what...
Breaking Into A Facility Using Canned Air Tested on Jan 28, 2020
Access control is supposed to make doors more secure, but a $5 can of compressed air may defeat it. With no special training, intruders can...
Halo Smart Vape Detector Tested on Jan 16, 2020
The Halo Smart Sensor claims to detect vaping, including popular brand Juul and even THC vapes. But how well does it work in real world...
Hikvision DS 2nd Gen Intercom Tested on Dec 12, 2019
With its newest IP intercom, Hikvision proclaims users can 'get full control over an entrance' regardless of where it is installed, home or office...
Hidden Camera Detectors Tested on Nov 18, 2019
Hidden cameras are a growing problem as cameras become smaller, cheaper and easier to access. However, some companies claim to be able to detect...
Access Control Door Controllers Guide on Oct 22, 2019
Door controllers are at the center of physical access control systems connecting software, readers, and locks. Despite being buried inside...
Securing Access Control Installations Tutorial on Oct 17, 2019
The physical security of access control components is critical to ensuring that a facility is truly secure. Otherwise, the entire system can be...
Lasers Impact on Surveillance Cameras Tested on Sep 25, 2019
Hong Kong protests have brought global attention to video surveillance and the ongoing attempts of protesters to disable or undermine those cameras...
Commend ID5 Intercom Tested on Sep 12, 2019
Commend touts the new ID5 intercom as 'timelessly elegant' and the slim body, glass front touchscreen indeed looks better than common, but ugly,...
Camera Disruptor Wyze Enters Sensor / Security Market on Mar 28, 2019
Wyze, the company that has disrupted consumer IP cameras, combining American marketing and Chinese manufacturer, has just announced its expansion...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Athena CEO Criticizes 'Deplorable' 'Nitpicking', IPVM Refutes on Mar 27, 2020
Athena Security's CEO Lisa Falzone has strongly objected to IPVM's reporting on Athena, calling it 'deplorable' and repeatedly criticizing IPVM's...
Hikvision Admits Sanctions Harming Its Financial Performance on Mar 27, 2020
While Hikvision initially downplayed being sanctioned for human rights abuses, the company is now admitting a significant impact in a new PRC...
New Axis M30 Cameras Tested on Mar 26, 2020
Axis has released a new generation of, for them, relatively low cost M30 series cameras, claiming to deliver "sharp video quality even in poor...
Coronavirus Shuts Down ADT Door Knockers on Mar 26, 2020
Coronavirus has another victim - this time, alarm giant ADT has stopped all door to door sales. Door knockers are a critical but controversial...
Access Control Course Spring 2020 - Save $50 Last Day on Mar 26, 2020
Register Now - Spring 2020 Access Control Course. Today, March 26th is the last day to save $50. IPVM offers the most comprehensive access...
Convergint Coronavirus Cuts on Mar 25, 2020
One of the world's largest security integrators, Convergint, has made a major move to handle the impact of coronavirus, with cuts across the...
VSaaS 101 on Mar 25, 2020
Video Surveillance as a Service (VSaaS) is the common industry term for cloud video. But what does it mean? How does it all work? Inside this...
TVT / InVid Facial Recognition Tested on Mar 25, 2020
Facial recognition is frequently sold for thousands of dollars per channel but some China manufacturers are offering full facial recognition...
IPVM Launches On-Demand Courses on Mar 24, 2020
For nearly a decade, IPVM has been a leader in online live courses. Now, we have added on-demand versions for all courses. The same course...