ACLU Fooled by Vendor Propaganda

Author: John Honovich, Published on Feb 07, 2011

The ACLU's surveillance concerns are based on technology that does not work in the real world. Ironically, the ACLU is indirectly promoting technology that surveillance professionals know is little more than smoke and mirrors. The ACLU would be more accurate and helpful attacking the ineffectiveness of this technology and the wasted money spent on it.

Specifically, the ACLU's report charges that 3 technologies used in public surveillance are invasive:

  • PTZ Cameras
  • Facial Recognition
  • Automatic Tracking of Objects Across Cameras

While PTZ cameras are mature technology used by everyone, everywhere, the other two technologies do not work in public surveillance. Indeed, vendors would love that it did but even they know it does not.

Update: The City of Chicago responded, denying they use facial recognition or automatic tracking of people. This is not surprising as, even if they did, the technology would work terribly in their environment.

In pilots and small scale controlled deployments, facial recognition and automatic tracking using public surveillance cameras can be done with moderate accuracy. However, once you start dealing with lots of objects, lots of cameras and various lighting scenes - critical in public surveillance such as Chicago - accuracy problems go through the roof. 

For facial recognition, in public surveillance, you need to identify a single person out of millions with an image that is routinely poor (with sharp angles of incident from the camera and lighting issues impacting quality - bright sunlight during the day, too dark at night). Even facial recognition for verification in controlled environments is still questionable and that's much much easier to do than public surveillance facial identification.

Tracking people and cars across cameras suffers from similar challenges. In a public environment, you can have dozens of people and cars moving simultaneously who 'look' very similar. They can be obstructed by larger objects like poles and buildings. The camera's view may be impacted by bright sunlight or shadows that further obscure people or cars. Sizable gaps frequently exist between camera coverage where objects can easily be lost. It's just not possible for computers to do this with any degree of accuracy at scale.

Any video surveillance professional signing on to deliver such systems would need a death wish. Indeed, it's well accepted within the industry that video analytics is still struggling to provide basic detection and cannot deliver these magical solutions.

Worse, since 9/11, governments have spent hundred of millions on video analytic systems that have not worked. 

Could this technology be invasive? Sure, if they worked but that's not the problem we are faced with today in 2011.


Related Reports on Facial Recognition

Lighthouse Deep Learning Camera Tested on Dec 07, 2017
A Silicon Valley startup, Lighthouse, with a Stanford PhD CTO, has released a deep learning AI camera with 3D sensors for just $300. The company...
BBC Featured Deep Learning Face Recognition Analyzed (Digital Barriers) on Aug 30, 2017
The UK's largest broadcaster, BBC, recently featured Digital Barriers (also based in the UK) on a segment highlighting face recognition technology....
Nest Cam IQ Tested on Jul 10, 2017
Nest has released their latest entry in their camera line, the Nest Cam IQ, touting 4K "Supersight", facial recognition, "HD audio", invisible IR,...
Bill Gates Funded Startup Evolv Gets $18M For The "Most Advanced Threat Detection System" on Mar 17, 2017
Evolv Technologies has just raised $18 million, bringing its total to $30M, for developing what the company says is the most advanced threat...
Face Recognition Camera Tested (Netatmo) on Jan 29, 2016
Can face recognition make home security "better"? That is the bold claim from startup Netatmo with their Welcome camera. But with face...
Simplicam Facial Recognition Tested on Jan 23, 2015
Facial recognition, available for $150? That's the offer from a startup, Simplicam, who has not only cloned Dropcam setup and user interface but...
Japanese Stores Facial Recognition Sharing on Apr 21, 2014
A controversy is brewing in Japan after a newspaper was tipped off about a practice stores use to combat shoplifting. A network of stores uses...
Debunking Start-Up's FST21 Case Study on Oct 07, 2013
This company won ISC West Best in Show 2 years ago, recently received $5 million in funding and is being talked about as the next big thing in...
The Laziest RFP Ever on Aug 13, 2013
Bad RFPs - out of date, vague or just plain confusing - are common. But this RFP is on a whole other level. It is as if no one even looked at...
3VR Significant Layoffs on Jun 28, 2013
3VR has laid off 15 employees, five of which are from its sales team, IPVM has learned. This leaves the company with a skeleton crew of three sales...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Imperial Capital Security Investor Conference Review on Dec 08, 2017
Investment bank Imperial Capital holds an annual Security Investor Conference where 60+ companies present, including this year: IPVM bought a...
Integrator GPS Vehicle Tracking Statistics and Success Examined on Dec 08, 2017
GPS vehicle tracking is a growing but somewhat controversial topic. On the plus side, tracking may increases productivity by providing greater...
Hikvision NA Biggest Sale of 2017 on Dec 07, 2017
Hikvision North America has been relatively disciplined the past 5 months, reducing the number of sales and the breadth of what is on sale. No...
Security Integrator IT Expertise Statistics on Dec 07, 2017
20 years ago, putting physical security systems on IP networks was just emerging. Today, almost every system is networked in some way, IP cameras...
Lighthouse Deep Learning Camera Tested on Dec 07, 2017
A Silicon Valley startup, Lighthouse, with a Stanford PhD CTO, has released a deep learning AI camera with 3D sensors for just $300. The company...
Access Control Course Winter 2018 on Dec 07, 2017
Learn more below about the Winter 2018 IPVM Access Control Course. Register here. IPVM offers the most comprehensive access control course in...
Broken Hikvision App Exposes Hypocrisy on Dec 06, 2017
While Hikvision talks about a commitment to cybersecurity, their broken app and their insecure 'solution' exposes not only their engineering...
'Catastrophic Problem' For Videofied App on Dec 06, 2017
Less than 2 months after closing their DIY division DragonFly, Videofied has been hit with a problem the company calls 'catastrophic'. Now the...
ASIS Dumps 'ASIS' For Show on Dec 06, 2017
After 60+ years, ASIS is dumping its eponymous show name and replacing it with 'GSX'. This is a classic marketing mistake. For a show struggling...
Risks Of Managing End User Passwords (Statistics) on Dec 05, 2017
Integrators know admin passwords for nearly all end-user systems, according to IPVM statistics. But how do they manage them? How do they ensure...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact