Long Range UHF Readers For Gate Entry Apps ...Nedap Or Tagmaster? Anyone Have Experience With Either?

Undisclosed Integrator #1

06/25/18 09:54pm

Looking at a good sized gate entry project for vehicle gates. Looking at both Nedap and Tagmaster long range UHF readers to propose. Anyone have recent experience, good or bad, with either of these manufacturers?

Their readers and credentials appear somewhat similar, so not sure what the differentiators are .. price, performance, reliability, and support are all critical. Since these types of reader aren't inexpensive, I figured I'd check here for input.

We will be using the readers in a simple wiegand-output mode to a separate access control system, so no fancy bells and whistles are required for managing the readers.

Thanks in advance.

Login to read this IPVM discussion.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.
Avatar

Brian Rhodes

IPVMU Certified | 06/26/18 02:31am

*** **** ******* **** will **** ** ** issued? **** ******** **** need ** ** **** simultaneously ** * ****** reader?

Undisclosed Integrator #1

06/26/18 11:32am

*,***+ ****/***** ****** *** **** ******** *********** ***** *****. **** one ** * **** ***** ** ** **** ******** **** entry ****** **** **** ******** ***** *****, **** **** ***** own *******.

Undisclosed End User #3

In reply to Undisclosed Integrator #1 | 06/26/18 01:04pm

** *** ***** ** our ********* ** ******* 5000 ****, ** ******** gates, *** **** *** good **** **** *** readers *** ****. ** its **** ***** *** just **** ** ** careful **** *** **** are ***** *** ***** tags *** ******. ************ they **** * **** selection ** *** ***** from ********** *** ********* to ***** **** *** under *** **** ************. I ** *** **** experience **** *** ***** brand *********. *** ******* issues ** **** *** was **** ******* ** the **** ******, ******** loops, *** *** ***** but **** *** *** mistake *** ********* *** manufacturer/integrator, **** *******, ***** support ** ***** *** sale.

Undisclosed Integrator #1

In reply to Undisclosed End User #3 | 06/26/18 01:14pm

****** *** *** ******** ... *** **** ***** system **** ****/********** **** the "*****" ****** ******* system *** ******** ******, or *** ** ********** standalone? ** ** *** tied **, *** *** use *** ** *** multi-technology ***** **** **** at **** *** ***** readers *** *** ************ prox ******* ** ******** doors?

Undisclosed End User #3

In reply to Undisclosed Integrator #1 | 06/26/18 01:32pm

** **** ** **** in ** *** ***** Access *******. ** **** separate *** ******* *** our ****** ******** ****** in *** ***** ********* are ** * ********* vehicle, ******** **** * different ********, ***.

Undisclosed #2

06/26/18 12:22pm

* **** **** ***** for ***** * *****, long ****** ***'* ******* was ** *** ******. So *** *** **** a ***** *******, ******* complaint ** *** ***** are ******* ** **** the *********** *** *** take ****. ** *** need ****** ****** ***/****, add **** **** *** some *** *****. ** fairness, *** *** **** on ***** *** ******** significantly *** *** ************* between *** *********** *** distribution ** **** ****. The **** ***** *** been ********** **** ** challenging ************, **** ********* side ******* ******, ******* credential **** ****** **** through ****** **+% ** the ***** ***.

Undisclosed Integrator #1

In reply to Undisclosed #2 | 06/26/18 01:05pm

****** *** *** ********. At **** ****** *** you ***** *** ***** readers? **** *** **** them **** ** ***** mounting *******, *.*. ** the **** ****** ** a ****** **** ******* like ** *** ******** might ** ******* (***** at ****** ****** ** an ******* ***)?

Avatar

Vlad Craciunescu

06/26/18 12:34pm

** **** ***** ***** Reach ***** * ***, most ******* *** **** access ** ** *******. They **** **** **** and *** ****** ******** forward. ***** *** ******* - ******* ****** ****** with ********* ******* *********** - ***** ** **** high *** *** ***********

*** **** ***** * don't **** *** **** will **** ** **** one ****** ** **** lane. * ***** *** coverage ** *** **** well ********** (** ***** be *** ) *** then *** **** ** orient **** *********** ( and/or **** ** ********* lines) ** **** ****** only **** **'* ****. Depending ** **** ********** it ***** **** ** mention *** ********** ****** (UHF **** ) *** some ********* ********* *** can ****/****** ***** * lot ** **** ** the **** ****.

* ***'* **** **** about ***** *** ************ and ******* ** **** area .

Undisclosed Integrator #1

In reply to Vlad Craciunescu | 06/26/18 01:10pm

***** *** *** **** info. ** **** **********, how ********* *** ***** readers ** ******* ******** direct **** ** ***** ... ****** ******* ** the *****-**** *****, **** though **** **** ** in **** **** **** other, ***** ***** ** some ******** ****** ******* lanes. ****'* **** *** the *** ******* *** about ***** ******/******* *******.

Avatar

Jon Jones

06/26/18 01:19pm

** *** ******** **** radios ** *** ** most *** ***. ** you *** ***** *** readers *** *** **** yourself * ********* ******** by ******** *** *********** they *** *** ************** vs. **** ********* ** make **** *** *** not ***** ** ****** interference ******.

Top Comment Votes - Past 3 Months
  • 1. John Honovich - 2002
  • 2. Chris Dearing - 929
  • 3. Brian Karas - 649
  • 4. Marty Major - 348
  • 5. Morten Tor Nielsen - 308
  • 6. Michael Miller - 282
  • 7. Sean Nelson - 259
  • 8. Brian Rhodes - 259
  • 9. Shannon Davis - 243
  • 10. Michael Silva - 214
  • 11. Sean Patton - 180
  • 12. Jay Hobdy - 152
  • 13. Ethan Ace - 150
  • 14. Brandon Knutson - 144
  • 15. Tim Pickles - 142
  • 16. Carl Lindgren - 137
  • 17. Jon Dillabaugh - 126
  • 18. Clint Hays - 114
  • 19. Greg Cortina - 111
  • 20. Stephen Green - 87
Manufacturers
Tools

AI Tester

BestMatch

Camera Calculator

Camera Finder

F-Stop Calculator

Chat

Integrator Finder

News Spider

Camera Comparison

Quizzes

Pages

About

Contact