How Well Can You Tell A Real Camera From A Dummy Camera?

Carlton Purvis

Jumping off the discussion about the man who had a camera pointed at his neighbor's hot tub, a lot of you work with cameras on a daily basis so I'm wondering: How well do you think you can tell a real camera from a dummy camera in the wild? The camera below is mounted outside of a club in DC in an area known to be pretty rowdy at night. The place was closed when I took the picture, but I plan to go back some other time to find out if it's real or not. To me, it looks a lot like a UniquExceptional, but considering the area, I can believe it might be real.

Show oldest first Show newest first

Brian Rhodes

IPVMU Certified | 09/24/13 01:57am

I'll just get this out of the way now: Was there a red blinking light on it?

Carlton Purvis

In reply to Brian Rhodes | 09/24/13 02:02am

That would have been helpful in discerning, but no blinking light on this one.

John Honovich

IPVM | In reply to Carlton Purvis | 09/24/13 02:04am

And that's probably, ironically, a positive sign that it is a real camera.

Can you see cabling running out and through the wall? No cabling means either a very clean install or it's a dummy. Do you have a picture of the back/other side of the camera? That would help.

Carlton Purvis

09/24/13 02:10am

I didn't see any cabling either. When I go back over there I'll get more picture of it during the day. That should help. It was raining out but I had to stop and get the picture because it looked so much like the dummy cameras.

Daniel Tyrrell

09/25/13 04:01am

Honestly looks like a real camera to me. Though I will say I have used 'Real (broken) Cameras' as dummies by simply just mounting them without wiring them.

Carlton Purvis

10/10/13 05:21pm

When today and got some daytime shots of this camera. The owner wasn't there to tell me more about it.

Here's what I know now:

There is red sensor, but not a blinking red light.
There is a single wire coming out the back of the camera
The camera says "Nuvico Day/Night" on the side.

Brian Karas

In reply to Carlton Purvis | 10/10/13 05:26pm

It is (or was) a legit camera. The red sensor is a CDS cell for turning on the IR LEDs in low light.

John Honovich

IPVM | In reply to Carlton Purvis | 10/10/13 05:35pm

Nuvico? That's a real camera, just not a very good one :)

Enrique Delgado

11/12/13 03:46pm

I think the main way to tell if it's a dummy or not is by the cabling.

John Honovich

IPVM | In reply to Enrique Delgado | 11/12/13 05:35pm

Enrique, see our Dummy Camera Shootout, which shows that dummy camera manufacturers have gotten more sophisticated with realistic 'dummy cabling'.

Discussion	Posts	Latest
Where Is The Real State Of The Art Network Access Controller ???? (1) Started by ROBERT VERHULST	1	less than a minute by ROBERT VERHULST
Imagine You Were Just Hired To Lead Hikvision... What Would You Do To Combat IPVM? (6) Started by Undisclosed #1	6	about 3 hours by Undisclosed #3
Looking For Alternative To DMP (11) Started by Undisclosed Integrator #1	11	about 1 hour by Undisclosed Integrator #1
Clear Written Instructions And A S**T Load Of Check Lists Are The Answers To Most Of Your Tech Problems (9) Started by Undisclosed Integrator #1	9	about 2 hours by Lee Brown
Accurate PTZ + Joystick For Object Tracking (5) Started by Fredrik Ahlsen	5	7 minutes by Lee Brown

Discussion

Posts

Latest

Where Is The Real State Of The Art Network Access Controller ???? (1)

Started by ROBERT VERHULST

less than a minute by ROBERT VERHULST

Imagine You Were Just Hired To Lead Hikvision... What Would You Do To Combat IPVM? (6)

Started by Undisclosed #1

about 3 hours by Undisclosed #3

Looking For Alternative To DMP (11)

Started by Undisclosed Integrator #1

about 1 hour by Undisclosed Integrator #1