Subscriber Discussion

Help: Analytics That Detect Person Wearing Cap Or Dark Glasses And If A Second Person Comes Into A Restricted Area

FG
FELIPE GARRIDO
Mar 14, 2018
SERMEX

hello Friends:

My company is working now with a project where they are requesting to use Analytics. They want to do as follows:

 

Identify the moment when a person jumps into a restricted area where there is already a person working. Trip wire does not work because there is a counter and there is one person working inside showing some jewerly to customers. They need to detect it, so the main control room needs to receive an alarm, or video popup window to very if its an emergency of a robery.

Second, they want to detect and alarm the main control center if someone wear a cap or dark glasses, do you think is there a possibility of detect this?

I would appreciate your advice and experiences......

 

JH
John Honovich
Mar 14, 2018
IPVM

Identify the moment when a person jumps into a restricted area where there is already a person working. 

So, Felipe, if there are 2 people in a defined area, you want to trigger an alarm? Is that right? If so, I think there are solutions, think of it like a queue line application where the queue is defined as 2. Main thing I worry about is whether there are any times or scenarios where another person comes into that area that would be legitimate. That would be hard for analytics to handle.

Second, they want to detect and alarm the main control center if someone wear a cap or dark glasses, do you think is there a possibility of detect this?

There are some forensic tools that claim to be able to search for such characteristics but I don't recall any mainstream offering claiming to alert on them.

I am curious what others add.

FG
FELIPE GARRIDO
Mar 14, 2018
SERMEX

Yes John: in the first one you are right. There are not other scenarios that apply, Just one person should be there always. 

 

In the second one, the tool should not be forensic, both features/analytics, should be in live stream, so they can be aware of a probably robery if the tool can detect somebody with a cap in his head, and/or dark glassess, do you think is there some tool like that?, if so please help me contact them?

 

ps
paul sun
Mar 18, 2018

Felipe,

This is Paul Sun from IronYun. We have a deep learning Intrusion detection analytics that can help. You can visit our website or drop me a note for more info.

Paul

UM
Undisclosed Manufacturer #1
Mar 14, 2018

Hi Felipe,

Both your use cases can be achieved. below is how you can do it.

1) For scenario one you can apply crowd formation. Here you can set threshold of 2 which means as soon a 2nd person is seen there is a trigger.

2) Training a network for hats/sunglasses can be done and below is screenshot where it detects person wearing a red hat. Person with Hat

PM me if interested and we can discuss.

 

(1)
JH
John Honovich
Mar 14, 2018
IPVM

Who are you? What commercially do you offer to do the hat/sunglasses offering? 

Finally, if you are promoting your offering, you have to disclose yourself. You also cannot be PM'ed being undisclosed.

(4)
FG
FELIPE GARRIDO
Mar 14, 2018
SERMEX

John: I dont want to cause a problem, I just want to know if someone had the same project or same situation than me and know how was solved. I respect your site IPVM and dont want to make a disturb, but how we can be in touch with people that can offer under a request a solution for a problem?, Please tell me the guidelines and I promese you to follow it.

 

Thanks a lot.

 

SY
Suresh Yendrapalli
Mar 14, 2018
Duranc

John, This is Suresh from Duranc. I earlier posts i was asked not to promote and was  answering to the post that things can be done and how they can be done. Duranc platform has certain capabilities today that can be done but didn't disclose as we were told not to use for promotional purposes.

If the member is interested and wants to contact us he can always approach through you as you know who we are or the poster is.

Any custom object detection involves more details and requirements and commercials cant be defined from a single post.

Having said that crowd formation is part of our analytics offering and $25/camera/month.

Regards,

Suresh

 

 

 

(1)
Avatar
Gianni Viero
Mar 14, 2018
Videotec

Hola Felipe

Iss offers a specific analytics for missing helmet (I believe this is used in the mining industry). Not sure if this can be tweaked for your application.

Thank you 


Gianni

FG
FELIPE GARRIDO
Mar 14, 2018
SERMEX

Excellent, Thanks a lot Gianni...It may work, 

Avatar
Gil Rene
Mar 15, 2018
Bosch

The question as always with analytics is not can something be done, it is "can something be done reliably." How mission critical is accuracy? I have been involved with analytics for over 12 years, and I would never claim anything close to 100% accuracy on detection of a particular event or trigger. I am a sales engineer with Bosch, and have deployed hundreds, probably thousands of channels of analytics. The biggest problem is managing expectations. The CSI Effect. We have very advanced analytics which perform very well in most circumstances, and are free in the camera. No additional license, no extra charges. And when someone wants to try a novel use or a tricky application, we supply a demo camera to setup and try in the real world, on location. It is irrelevant how it performs in the lab.

If 100% accuracy is needed, analytics is most likely not the answer. I always advise my customers that analytics job is to say, "You said if this happens, to let you know. I think it just happened. You need to look now". Its job is to reduce the amount of video data that must be reviewed, but it still requires what I call the "human Filter".

So finally, whatever technology you are investigating, "Try before you buy!".

(8)
(3)
FG
FELIPE GARRIDO
Mar 15, 2018
SERMEX

Hello Gil:

 

Well Yes, thanks for your sincere and valuable opinion, you are right. I will cool down my customer expectatives, I am just like you, when somebody offer this kind of analytics, I need to test it first in order to open my mouth to the end user.

 

Thanks for sharing your expeiences.

 

(1)
U
Undisclosed #2
Mar 18, 2018

I added an 'Agree' to this comment because I believe it is in the integrators interest to set customer expectations accordingly.

If what they want can't be done reliably - then it is to the benefit of the integrator to let their customers know this fact... with maybe some similar/emerging options that might work in the future, once vetted by the integrator.

Avatar
Leonard Frost
Mar 18, 2018
Wanco

You might be able to do this with American Dynamics and CCURE with a facial recognition add-on.

I imagine you could setup an analytic rule that confirms a face is detectable (no hat, no sunglasses), if not, then trigger a CCURE output that could activate an alarm or lock down a facility.

You could also achieve the "jewelry customer escort" rule by setting an analytic configuration that alerts when two objects are more than a certain distance apart. It might also serve to monitor when an escort leaves a customer unattended, which might also be a security risk. 

JH
John Honovich
Mar 18, 2018
IPVM

I imagine you could setup an analytic rule that confirms a face is detectable (no hat, no sunglasses), if not, then trigger a CCURE output that could activate an alarm or lock down a facility.

Leonard, how does that determine if "someone wear a cap or dark glasses"? How does face detection accomplish that?

FG
FELIPE GARRIDO
Mar 18, 2018
SERMEX

Thanks Leonard, I will try to ask for a solution to the representatives of the brand down here in Mexico, if any,

 

Thanks a lot.

 

Avatar
Carter Maslan
Mar 19, 2018
Camio

@Felipe FD I'm CEO of Camio. If you provide sample videos, we can give you precision  and recall numbers for your particular resolution/camera angle/lighting so that you know whether the solution works that way your customer needs it to. It won't be perfect, so it's a matter of determining whether there's an acceptable rate of false positives and false negatives. For example, customers want us to detect hooded night intruders and Camio search results include false positives from very similar hats and head-related gear: https://camio.com/c/91puhvzvry0w/app (all can be improved, but level-setting in scene PPF like this)

FG
FELIPE GARRIDO
Mar 19, 2018
SERMEX

Carter, Thanks a lot for your suggestion, I will ask the customer, because they dont want to send out footage of their installations.

 

Thanks a lot but I will contact you.

 

 

Avatar
Carter Maslan
Mar 19, 2018
Camio

To clarify, they don't have to share footage with anyone external if they're willing to judge the accuracy themselves.

FG
FELIPE GARRIDO
Mar 19, 2018
SERMEX

Hello John:

 

I am proud and happy to belong to this community. I am member since more than 3 years and this is the first time I ask for help, and its good that I got it, a lot of experiences and advices, that's good.  Thanks John and thanks to all community.

 

 

(1)
New discussion

Ask questions and get answers to your physical security questions from IPVM team members and fellow subscribers.

Newest discussions