Subscriber Discussion

Help Me Choose A Camera For A Store

UE
Undisclosed End User #1
Aug 22, 2013

I'm looking at buying a fix camera for IP surveillance and I'm having a hard time deciding what to go for. I read the various articles available but still can't get a clear answer. Here are the things I need to take into account:

  • Fix camera.
  • Camera will cover a store front about 30' wide.
  • Camera will be between 150' and 250' from the scene.
  • Camera should be able to take pictures for identification purposes.
  • Moderate movements in the zone.
  • Should display good performances in low lighting conditions.
  • Bandwidth/Storage is a concern.
  • Budget is not a major concern.

I don't want to take too much of your time so there's no need to justify your recommendation in great details, but your suggestions would be appreciated.

SM
Stanley Mezewski
Aug 22, 2013

There are a number of products that may work. I just bought a Honeywell 4 channel recorder for covert video. Look for a camera that has Wide Dynamic Range to account for the changes in lighting.

JG
John Grocke
Aug 22, 2013

Doing a quick calculation at ~200' with the Theia Lens Calculator, you are going to need a 1080p low light box-style camera with an aftermarket 15-50mm varifocal lens to get the 60ppf for identification as requested. A suggestion would be the Bosch NBN-932V that we reviewed in January with a Fujinon or similar 3MP 15-50mm lens. I was going to suggest the Axis P13 series, but they do not offer the low-light Lightfinder option in any higher resolution than 720p.

MG
Matt Golueke
Aug 26, 2013

Undisclosed,

You list the desires that many end users have: long range to target, desire to identify anywhere within that range, and limited bandwidth/storage. Here's the short answer from my perspective...

If you need to identify at a long range and at a short range with the same camera you are looking at a very high megapixel camera. If you go with high megapixel you are looking at high bit rates and thus high storage cost. The military came up with an acronym, DCRI, which essentially explains how to pick a camera lens based on the desired image capture result.

My advice is to meet with a few local manufacturer partners directly or with an integrator and do a demo of what you can see at 20' vs 200' with the same camera. They'll be glad to help, particularly if you have many retail stores to cover with cameras. John mentioned Bosch below (I'm a Bosch rep on the east coast) which is great, but you really should get a demo in order to set reasonable expectations for your system.

For more on DCRI, click here and select the last link on the page: http://midches.com/resources/downloads-technical-support/help-by-category/camera-systems/cctv-basics/

Best of luck,

Matt

New discussion

Ask questions and get answers to your physical security questions from IPVM team members and fellow subscribers.

Newest discussions