Best / Worst VMS Search Shootout: What Criteria Should We Test

We are starting a VMS Search Shootout and are evaluating what are the best features or capabilities to base the evaluation on. This is shootout is related to searching for recorded video, events, and alarms, not exporting (VMS Export Shootout - Avigilon, Dahua, Exacq, Genetec, Hikvision, Milestone).

The parameters/criteria we are starting out with (no specific order):

  • Event-based Search Features (type of events - alarm/motion/bookmarks, area of interest filtering)
  • Traditional Calendar/date-time Search Features
  • Thumbnail Search Capabilities (minimal clicks to find a left-behind/removed object is best)
  • Analytics Classification Search (object type, color, size. e.g. Avigilon Appearance Search)
  • UX Strengths and Weaknesses (search filter flow - left to right, top to bottom, etc, consistency in client design)
  • Multi-camera search/tracking capabilties
  • Mobile App Search Features

What other criteria or aspects should we be considering for our evaluation? Let us know in the comments.

Thanks!

Login to read this IPVM discussion.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

****** ****** ************ **** event ***** **** **** analytics ** *** ***** ingested ****. **** ****** video ****** **** **** based *** ***********/****** ***** analytics, *.*. ********* ******** cameras ** *** **** time *** * ********** classification. ** *** ******* this ******* * *** as ********* ****** **** popular *** **********.

*****!! **** ** **** have ******* ********* ******* but **** *** *** faster **** ******.

***** ** ** *** much ** **** ** with **** ***-****-***** *****? I ***** **** ****** surprised ** **** ***-****-***** users **** ******* ****. And ********* **** ******** me ** *** ****** they **** ** * feature **** ****** **** advanced.

** ***** ** **** to **** ******* *** ease ** *** ***** significantly **** *** *********. There *** **** ***'* that ** **** ******* because ******** ** ** team ******* **** ****** hard ** ***.

** ** *** ***** prove **** *****'* ******* wrong (**** ****, *****!) and **** ***** ******* are **** ** *** after ***, ****'* ** great. *******

*** **** ** *** VMS/software ******* *****, ** review *** ******** **** a ** ********** **** a ******* ****** ** Computer-Human *********** **** ******** University *** ******* **** review ***********. *** ***** of **** ****** ** to **** ** ******** and ********* **** *** poorly *********, **** ********* mechanics, ** *** ************ through *** ****** ********.

*** ***** ** *** list ******.

** ****, **** ** timely, ***** ** ****. Thank *** *** **** hard **** *** ********!

* ***** **** ** hear ***** **** ***** compatibility, ********** ** *** VMS ** ***** ******* in ** **** ** disparate ******* *** *******. We **** *********** ** much **** ***** **** the ***** **** ** comes ** ******* ***** truly ***** **********, *** would **** ** **** what *** **** ***-***********, open ******** **.

****, ******* *** **** more * *** * into ********, *** *** has *** **** ******** features ** **** ******** information.

*** ** ** ******* like ****, *** **** the ****** *******, *******, Milestone, *****, ****, ********? Not ********* *** *****?******* *******'* ******** ***** Management ********

*** **** **** *** mean ** *****. **** it ***** ** ***, I ***'* ***** ****'** that *** * ******, unless ****** **** *******.

****** **** **** ************* *****, ***** (*** Qognify), *****, *******, *** Video ******* ***** ** the **** ****. *** as *** ******* ******, votes *** ******** ****** Hikvision (*** **** ******** Axis *** *****) **** quite ***, ** ** you **** ** ******* big ******* *** ******* Hikua, ***** *** ***** four ** *** ****'* worth **********.

***,

*** ***** ********* ******** in **** **** ****** that *** ***** **** to *** ** *** VMS *******? *** *** recent *** ***** ** generally ***** ** *** feature ************ (******** ***** of *********, ******* **********, Milestone *********** ******, ***), and ***** **** ** basics **** "*** *** add * ******?" ****** there *** ******** *********** (Salient ******* ***** *******) or ********** ** * VMS.

**** *** *********, ** 2019 ** ****** (** no ******** *****):

***** ***** ******* ******** tests:

***** **** ** *** account *** ***** *** tests *** *******.

******* ****** *** / memory **** ******* *** products ***** ****** **** motion *********.

* ********* ****** ************ (minimal ****** ** **** a ****-******/******* ****** ** best)

* ******** **** ******* clicks ** "****". ** a *** **** ****** can ****** *** ***** time ***** ** ******* the ******, **** **** might ** ***** **. If **'* **** *** click, *** ** ***** 2 ***** ** **** the ****** ******** **** 1 ***** ** ******** worse. * ***** ******** also ***** ** ****** in - * ***** one ** ***** "*****" systems *** ** **** spewed *** ******** ** thumbnails **** ********* ****** ROI ***** (*** ** was ************ **** ** doing **). ** ********, the ******* *** *******. I ** **** **** with ******* ************* *** tweaking *** ******* ***** have **** ******, *** should ***** ***** **** be ******* ** **** of *** "***** *****"?

** ***** ** ********* cool ** *** ***** make *** ********** *** use *** ******* ********* to *** ******* (** a ***** *.*** **** or **** ********* ** YouTube).

******, ****** *** *** feedback *** ********. * agree **** **** ******* at ******* ****** ** probably *** ********, *********** the ******* ******** **** to ******** *** ****** is **** *********. **** we **** **** ** weighing ** *** ************ within *** ********* ******, result ******** ***** (*** long ** ***** ** filter "****" ** *** next ***** ** **********), and ** ****** (******* flow - **** ** right, *** ** ******, etc).

** ******* ** * lower ******* ********* ****** would ** **** *********'* pre-2019 ** ******** ********, which *** **** *******, with ******** **** ** controls, ******* ** *** left, ********** ** *** bottom, ****** ** *** top, *** * ******* thumbnail ******** *******:

** *** ******** ****, results ********* ******* *** it ****** ******* ****** smoothly, *** ******* *** UX *** * *********** negative *** **** *****.

**********... ******* *********** (***, memory...etc..etc)

**** ** *** ****** expected ** ** ********?

** ** *** **** an ******* ********** **** at **** ****, *** it **** ** ** the **** * ****** (December - *******).

*** *************!

******** ** ***** ***? Just * ****, **** shootout ** ******* ** the *** ******'* ********* features.

****** **** *** *** mobile *** ********* *** searching ******.

* *** ******** ********* quite ********** ***** *** it's ** ********* ** find ****** ***** ***** professional-grade *** ***, **** their **** **** / Nest ****** ** ** much *******.

** / ********* ********* is *** ********* *** this.

****** *** *** ******** Brian, * **** ********** include ****** *** *********.

************* **** ******** ******** system ** *****, ***** in **** **** ** end **** ** **** to *** ********* ***/** better ****** ***** *** not *********** ****** *** our ******.

****.

**** *** *** **********, Test *** *** *********.

****** **** ******* ** other *******, ****** *** us **** *** ******* and ************** ** **** testing.

**********, * *** **** take ** **** ** on *********, ***, *** and *** ***** *****.

** *** *** **.

**** **** ***/****** ********.

*******....

***** ** ******* **** this ******** ******** ***** in *** ******** **** each *******.

** *********: ** ***** that ** *** **** what ******** **..*** ***** any ******* ****** **** an *** ********* ****** setup **** ** **********.

**

* ** ******* ** use ******** *** ******* with ********. ***** **** to *** ******** ****** Avigilon ******* ******.

*** ******** ********* *** that ******* ***** ***** cameras.....does **** ***** **** enough *********** ** *** the **** ******* ** a ******** *** *** Aviligon ****** *****....**** ** you **** ** *********** and *** ***** ********* pitfalls?

*** *** *** *** same ******* ******** **** if *** *** ********'* AI *** **** *** party *******. ***** *** the ** *** **** H4 ********* ****** ********* that **** ******** ** H5 ****.

****** ******* ********** **** response. * ******** *** Avigilon **** ***** *** cameras ** *** ******* when *** *** *** 16 ******* ** *** the ** **** ******* with * ***** **** PTZ . **** *** ANPR ****** **** * third ***** **** *** on *** *** ** must **** ** *********. Likewise **** ***/**** ** cameras ** ** *** unit ******* *****.

***** **** ****** **** your ********** ****** ***** - ***** ***

**** * **** *** AI *** ** ** analytics *** *** ******* have ** *********. **>** I ***** *** *** AI *** * **** over ** **** *** new ******* *** ** makes **** ***** ** replace ***** ******* **** H5 ******* ** **** get *** ******-*** ******* and *********.

******** *** **** ** the ****** ** **** not *** *** ** box ** ******* ****. This ** ******** *** channel *** *** *** any ****** ******.

** ****** **** *****, you ****** **** ******* completeview **** ** *** test.

** - ***** ******* is ****** ** ******* updates - ******** * dont **** ** **** extent / ********.

******

*** ****** **** ******* completeview **** ** *** test

** ************* ************ **/** *** Tested******* ** *** **** and ** / **** they *** ***** ** will ****** **** ****.

** ***'* ** ********* them ** *** ******** since ***** *** ****** of *** ********* *** Salient ** **** **** than *** **** ****** 5 ** ** ** include. **** ** ****** our ******* ********** ****, we *** ******* ********** to ***** ******* ***** compare / **** ** these ******** ********.

* **** ******* *****/****** Wave/ ** ******** ****** if *** **** ** on *** ****.

* ******** ****** ****... I ***** **** *** UI *** ** ** NetworkOptix ** **** ** class *** **** ********* for **** ********* *** non-technical *****.

*'* ******* *** * vms **** *** ** behavioral *********, **** ****** senors ***** ******* ******* maybe?

***** *** **** *** put ******** “*******” ** the **** ** ******** few ***** ***.

***** **********

*** *, ****

*** ** **** *** looking ** ******* ******** as * *** *** a ********* ******* **** requires ***** *** *********. Likely **** ********* **** Axis **** ********* *** a ****** **** *****. Less **** ** ***** cams. ****'* **** ** find * ****** ** Aimetis ******** ** ****. Any ******** ** *****, or ******** ** *******?

**** ********

*****, ** **** *** tested *******. ************, ** terms ** ****** ******** / ********, **** **** not **** **** ** companies *********** **** ********** cite (**** *****, *********, Genetec, ********, ***., *** Favorite *** ************* ****). To *** ******, ** saw*****, ** *** ** line **** **** *** are ********** - *** integrated *********.

** ***** **** **** in **** ** ***** their ***********, **** **** been ******* ** ***** hires ***** ****** ***** more *********** **** ******** them.

*******, *** *******, *** less ******** / ********, from **** ** **** seen, ****** * ***** ago. ** ****, ** would *** **** ***** to ******* **** ** the ******** ***** ***. More *******, ** *** probably **** ****** ** do ** ********** **** on *******/******* ***** ****.