Top 10 Surveillance Myths Debunkedby John Honovich, IPVM posted on Jun 25, 2011 About John Contact John
Aggressive marketing creates dangerous myths. Vendors transform their product's highest aspirations into concrete claims. Unfortunately, these become generally accepted 'knowledge' that helps sales, hurts users and sometimes crushes a market (such as video analytics).
In this report, we examine 10 of the most serious myths facing the video surveillance industry. Our analysis is based on the systematic results of our testing program that disproved these claims.
Here are the 10:
- Myth: Resolution Comparison Diagram
- Myth: More Pixels = Higher Image Quality
- Myth: A Megapixel Camera is Equal to Many SD Cameras
- Myth: Pixels Per Foot is a Reliable metric
- Myth: WDR Camera Specifications are Legitimate
- Myth: Minimum Illumination Specifications are Legitimate
- Myth: Superior Low Light Performance Claims
- Myth: IR Illuminators Massively Reduce Bandwidth Consumption
- Myth: VSaaS is Secure and Mature
- Myth: 80% Analytics are Good Enough
- Myth: Megapixel 'Virtually Eliminates' PTZ Cameras
What Do You Think?
Here's how your peers voted:
Most of you have seen megapixel comparison charts where overlayed boxes show how much more higher resolution cameras can capture than lower resolution ones. Here's an example:
While the layout varies by vendor, this is an industry wide technique.
These resolution comparison charts are dangerously misleading because they imply that all pixels are equal.
Here' an analogy. Let's say I claimed:
- A 600 pound man can lift twice as much as a 300 pound man.
The assumption is clear as it is wrong. While more weight often correlates with more strength, this is far from universal.
- More weight does not guarantee more power. More pixels does NOT guarantee more details. Period.
This flawed assumption is the basis of a number of other myths and might be the most serious issue our industry faces as we attempt to properly integrate megapixel surveillance.
Inside the Pro section, we dig into each myth, explain why it is wrong and what you should do to avoid becoming a victim.
Most Recent Industry Reports
Testing the Resolution of the Human Eye on Dec 04, 2013
All sorts of wild guesses and theoretical calculations exist about what the resolution of the human eye is, with 576MP a common claim. No one we can find has ever actually tested it . . . until no...
Hikvision Cameras Tested on Dec 02, 2013
Hikvision claims to be the #1 surveillance manufacturer in the world. That's, well, debatable. What's not in dispute is that they have become huge, fueled by the massive Chinese market, with ...
Testing New Dropcam Pro Camera on Nov 25, 2013
VSaaS, overall, has been a disaster with nearly every provider, including gorilla Axis, struggling to make it big. The one clear exception has been Dropcam. It's end to end solution, targeted for ...
Bosch Flexidome Micro Shootout on Nov 22, 2013
Minidomes are very popular, likely the most popular of all IP camera form factors, due to their relative low cost and small size. Earlier this year, we tested 3 Axis M30 minidomes. Now, we are test...
10MP vs 5MP vs HD Shootout on Nov 20, 2013
HD cameras are commonplace. Everyone offers 1080p. The big question now is how much better is 5MP or 10MP? Is a 10MP camera 5 times better than 1080p as pixel count proponents claim? In this repor...
VMS Mobile Apps Guide on Nov 19, 2013
Every VMS supplier has mobile app clients now, even if many are still not using them. However, significant differences can exist across VMS implementations. In this guide, we review 15 key feature...
Samsung Wisenet III Camera Shootout on Nov 18, 2013
Samsung has never been a serious player in IP cameras, despite their success in other markets. Now, Samsung is pushing their Wisenet III release as their breakthrough offering. Is it really? We b...
Camera Selection Guide on Nov 14, 2013
Entrances, hallways, rooms and parking lots are perhaps the 4 most common areas where surveillance is deployed. But what is the best type of camera for each? What resolution, form factors and FoV a...
Winners & Losers Fall 2013 on Nov 04, 2013
New product releases were terrible this fall. The biggest news was the debatable entry of Axis and Milestone into access control. But the biggest gains might be for Chinese manufacturers who are an...