The Indoor 7 Camera Shootoutby Antony Look, posted on May 28, 2011
Indoors, surveillance cameras are used all over. Given the generally small areas monitored and their shelter from the weather, getting good surveillance video is easier than outdoors. It raises the question: Does it even matter what type of surveillance cameras you use indoors? What type of practical differences or benefits does one camera provide over another?
We wanted to test this rigorously so we set up a 7 camera test kit to do a simultaneous shootout. In our kit we included cameras ranging from SD through 5MP from Arecont Vision, Avigilon, Axis, Bosch and Sony to see if more resolution helps, if D/N versus color only matters and if different manufacturers are 'better', etc.
We mounted our test kit in a corner at ceiling height as is common in real world installations.
We first tested during the day with even artifical lighting conditions to get a baseline test of an 'easy' scenario:
We tested with the shades open to see the impact of outdoor lighting through a window. Often businesses (like retailers) like to have the windows open to bring in natural light and to let prospective customers see in. We wanted to see what negative impact this might have on each camera:
Finally, we tested in the dark to see how cameras would perform after hours in case an intruder broke in. Since manufacturers use varying tricks at night, we did 2 tests here - one with manufacturer defaults and one with exposure normalized.
The overhead image and map below shows the coverage, areas, distances and pixels per foot at different testing positions. The human figure indicates the 3 spots where we performed analysis of image quality:
Analyzing Video Quality
We analyzed a series of scenes to see how performance varied across the cameras. We digitally zoomed each camera to the same level to show differences. See an example scene comparison from our parking lot test.
We conducted our analysis across 12 scenes. They are:
- Even Artificial Lighting (Doorway)
- Even Artificial Lighting (Far)
- Even Artificial Lighting (Near)
- Backlit/WDR via Open Window (Doorway)
- Backlit/WDR via Open Window (Far)
- Backlit/WDR via Open Window (Near)
- Front-lit via Open Window (Doorway)
- Front-lit via Open Window (Far)
- Front-lit via Open Window (Near)
- Low-Light (Default Settings)
- Low-Light (Normalized Settings)
- Low-Light Default vs Low-Light Normalized
Analyzing Bandwidth Consumption - NEW
Not only do we examine which cameras provide the best quality in each scene, we now break down the bandwidth consumption, showing who's the best and worse for the amount of network bandwidth and storage consumed.
Our analysis covers 7 metrics:
- Even Artificial Lighting Bandwidth Consumption Per Camera
- Backlight / WDR Bandwidth Consumption Per Camera
- Front-Lit Bandwidth Consumption Per Camera
- Low-Light (Default Settings) Bandwidth Consumption Per Camera
- Low-Light (Normalized Settings) Bandwidth Consumption Per Camera
- Average Bandwidth Consumption Per Scene
- Average Bandwidth Consumption Per Camera Overall
We found a suprising level of differences amongst cameras for image quality, bandwidth and overall performance. Contrary to common belief, more resolution did not always result in better image quality nor higher bandwidth. Inside the Pro section, we dig into the details and differences.
Most Recent Industry Reports
BREAKING: Tyco Acquires Exacq on Jun 19, 2013
Tyco is spending $150 million in cash to acquire VMS/NVR manufacturer Exacq, who generated $54.6 million in 2012. This is one of the most expensive and significant deals in the video surveillance i...
Axis MP Pinhole Shootout on Jun 18, 2013
For covert surveillance, pinhole lenses / cameras are a common choice because they can be hidden behind walls, or in ordinary objects. Until recently, the only options were analog / SD. However, Ax...
Testing Pelco Sarix IL10 on Jun 12, 2013
Value / budget cameras are becoming increasingly important for even 'professional' oriented manufacturers and are viewed as a key means to expand IP to the lower end of the market. This spring, Pel...
2013 Mid Year Surveillance Guide on Jun 11, 2013
The 229 page, 2013 Mid Year Surveillance Industry Guide, covering the key events and the future of the video surveillance market, is now available. Our Picks Here are some picks of key news and s...
Testing Advanced Drivercam on Jun 07, 2013
Most dash or driver cams have few features - they record audio and video to an SD card which you pull out and manually review. That is certainly the case with the top selling CarCam on Amazon which...
Axis Beats Patent Troll on Jun 05, 2013
Axis has beaten one of the biggest and most powerful patent trolls, landing an important victory for the surveillance industry. Two years ago, Walker Digital filed suits against Axis and other secu...
Testing Sony's 6th Gen IP Cameras on Jun 03, 2013
Sony's long awaited 6th generation IP cameras are now available. In our 2010-2011 tests, Sony's 5th generation cameras were one of the top offerings of that era. However, the market has advanced in...
Testing Avigilon's Image Enhancement on May 27, 2013
Typically, VMS software displays video 'as is'. While there may be basic brightness, contrast and saturation controls, those require manual adjustment with significant tradeoffs. By contrast, Avig...
30 vs 60 FPS Shootout on May 21, 2013
30 frames per second used to be the maximum practical limit for surveillance cameras. Now, it is becoming increasingly common for IP cameras to support double that, 60 frames per second. (For backg...
#1 IP Camera Benefit on May 19, 2013
Megapixel was, far and away, the number #1 cited benefit in going to IP cameras / video. We asked over 100 integrators to name the "3 biggest reasons" they found, allowing them to name whatever the...